On June 11, 2021, before City Council ever saw it, City staff emailed a draft stormwater ordinance to the builders’ trade group for comment. Twelve days later, the builders sent back their changes and asked the City to “share any changes you make prior to this going forward.”1
So the City writes its own rules, right? The rules that are supposed to keep new building from flooding the neighbors . . . those are written for the residents . . . right?
Nope. In Virginia Beach, the builders’ association, its lobbyist, and its engineers and attorneys get the drafts first, sit on the committees that rewrite them, and sit on the boards that hear the appeals. This post shows how, with the dates, the votes, and their own words.

The biggest conflict:
The builders’ association, funding eight sitting Council members $28,250, selecting the “external representatives” who rewrote the City’s stormwater rules in 2021, then seating its lobbyist and engineer on the committees that asked Council to roll the rules back.2
The builders edit the drafts first: The appeals board
The Stormwater Appeals Board hears builders who are turned down on the City’s stormwater rules. In 2021, three of its six seats belonged to City staff from Planning, Public Works, and Public Utilities. That year, staff proposed taking those votes away, “after hearing feedback regarding the make up of the board from the development community.”3
- June 11, 2021: City staff sends the draft ordinance to Claudia Cotton, chief executive of the CVBIA.1
- June 23, 2021: Cotton answers, copying Tuck Bowie, Brad Martin, Eric Keplinger of MEB, Jeff and John Ainslie, developer Mark Ricketts, and six others: “I’ve compiled comments from our members and others.” The builders’ objection: “The Board makeup excludes the development community . . . We strongly recommend including a civil engineer with a background in site design/stormwater.”4
- July 6, 2021: Council defers the ordinance “to obtain additional stakeholder input,” and directs staff to review all of the stormwater rules with the stakeholders.5, 6
- February 1, 2022: Council adopts the board the builders asked for, 10-0, on a motion by Linwood Branch, seconded by Guy Tower. City staff lose their votes. The seats now go to people with “civil engineering, land surveying, landscape architecture” backgrounds, and the July draft’s bar on members “actively involved in the submission of stormwater applications” is gone.7
The builders’ spokesman hears building code appeals, too. Bowie holds the “Construction Industry” seat on the Board of Building Code Appeals, appointed June 23, 2020 on Vice Mayor Jim Wood’s nomination and reappointed April 15, 2025 to May 31, 2030 on Henley’s.8
The builders rewrite the rulebook: Every Friday for three months
On August 6, 2021, three months before voters approved the flood bond, City staff began weekly meetings on the stormwater rules with a focus group of “External representatives selected by Coastal Virginia Building Industry Association (CVBIA),” developers, and consulting engineers. By December 14, 2021, 65 percent of their 86 recommendations were accepted or awaiting approval.5 Residents received three and a half weeks, December 21, 2021 to January 14, 2022, to comment online.6
What the builders won:
- Sea level rise, out: “Remove 1.5 ft of sea level rise from the 100-year design storm.”5
- Small projects, simpler math: “alternative design options for projects that have an increase of impervious area less than 20,000 square feet.”5
- Looser “no impact” test: “Align modeling tolerance of ‘no impact’ to align with Army Corps practice.”5
- Less study before a rezoning: “Reduce complexity of preliminary stormwater analysis.”5
On February 1, 2022, the same night the flood bond promise failed 5-5, Council adopted the rewritten chapter 10-0, on a motion by John Moss, seconded by Tower.9 The ‘ayes’ still sitting today are Berlucchi, Dyer, Barbara Henley, and Wilson. Four weeks later, Council had to vote again, because “the document presented to and approved by the City Council did not include the final revisions.”6
The builders’ own committee later bragged about the win, “Remove Sea Level Rise from the 100-year event analysis,” and admitted what they had been doing for more than 20 years under the old rule:
“We always met ‘rate of flow’; we always ignored ‘timing of runoff’.”10
The builders kill what voters were promised
To win the 2021 flood bond, Council promised to recommend denial of any project that adds stormwater. Bowie, Cotton, Martin, and Chris Wood spoke against it, and on May 3, 2022, Council shelved it, 6-5.11 Dear Eddie Bourdon told the Planning Commission: “we are basically saying we’re not open for business.” Council Member Moss answered: “What is really desired is relief from the stormwater management regulations.”12 The new Comprehensive Plan dropped the promise on April 21, 2026, 8-3.13 The full story is in Flood Bonding Out Developers. Who paid for and drafted the plan is in Comprehensive Plans Bought, Drafted, and Paid for by Developers.
The builders sit on the committees: “Objective and unbiased”
Council’s Process Improvement Steering Committee calls itself “an objective and unbiased collection of local talent.”14 Its first chairman, in 2011, was Bowie, the builders’ spokesman, using his Terry Peterson email. Martin was a founding member. By 2023, Martin was chairman and Bowie vice chairman.15
- January 2023: The committee briefs Council at its retreat and hands over “Stormwater Solutions.” It uses the residents’ flood bond as the reason to loosen the rules (“gives the City significant flexibility, which doesn’t require incremental solutions on every project and every property”), calls stormwater design before a rezoning “unnecessarily precise and burdensome for a developer,” and says “‘fixing flooding’ . . . aren’t realistic benchmarks to achieve.” It asks for a commission that could “revert back to the 2014 State Standards.”10
- May 28, 2024: The CVBIA gives Dyer $4,000.16
- June 4, 2024: Dyer and Schulman put the steering committee’s request on Council’s agenda.17
- June 18, 2024: Council creates the Stormwater Management Implementation Advisory Group, 9-2. The only ‘nays’ are Chris Taylor and Wooten.18
- July 2, 2024: On Wilson’s nomination, Council reappoints Bowie and Martin to the steering committee to June 30, 2027.19
- May 2, 2025: The new advisory group meets. Bowie and Ricketts hold the “real estate development community” seats, and Martin sits as a resident. Martin moves, and Ricketts seconds, to make land use attorney Christopher Pocta its chairman.20
- November 10, 2025: The group’s recommendations never mention the referendum or the promise. They point to the “Process Improvement Steering Committee (PISC) white papers” as the way to improve “predictability,” say “predictability of project viability is important to the development community,” and call for “continued dialogue” between “the development community and City staff” about City standards “which exceed state regulations.”21

2025: The Bay rules “accommodate” the economy
On August 19, 2025, Council rewrote the City’s Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area Ordinance by consent, 11-0, on a motion by Wilson, seconded by Berlucchi.22 Besides holding two public meetings, City staff briefed three City boards and one outside group: the CVBIA.23
- Out: the findings that Bay waters “have been degraded significantly by many sources of pollution, including nonpoint source pollution from land development” and “are worthy of protection from further degradation,” and the rule that Bay land “shall be developed in such manner as to protect the quality of water in the Bay.”24
- In: Bay land “shall be developed in such manner . . . that promotes water quality and accommodates for the economic vitality of the city.”22
- Also gone: the City’s own wider “variable width buffer outside the state-designated RPA.”23
The law
Terms: City Code § 2-3(a)(4) limits appointees to any City board or commission to two consecutive four-year terms, unless a majority of Council finds that going past that “would serve the best interests of the city” (§ 2-3(b)).25 Bowie has sat on the steering committee since it began in 2011, 15 years, and Martin has served on it continuously since June 16, 2015. The July 2, 2024 reappointments show no § 2-3(b) finding.19, 26
Conflicts: Both committees are “advisory agencies” under Va. Code § 2.2-3101. A member with a personal interest in a matter may take part only as one of a group of three or more affected persons, and only after filing the written declaration required by § 2.2-3115(H) (§ 2.2-3112(B)(1)). No declaration by Bowie, Martin, or Ricketts appears in the advisory group’s 2025 minutes, even though the Deputy City Attorney reviewed the Conflict of Interests Act with them on the first day.20
The builders’ money
Funding eight of the eleven sitting Council members, the CVBIA has given Wilson $8,750, Dyer $8,000, Berlucchi $3,000, Cummings $2,500, Schulman $2,500, Remick $1,500, Hutcheson $1,000, and Jackson-Green, a former steering committee member, $1,000.2 Every one of them voted ‘aye’ on the 2025 Bay rewrite.22
Before 2018:
Swimming pools and Bay buffers, 2008 and 2009: In June 2007, the state found the City out of compliance with the Chesapeake Bay Act. By September 2008, one item was left: counting swimming pools as impervious cover.27 On August 26, 2008, Martin and Eddie registered against the fix, and Council killed it 10-0, on Wilson’s motion, seconded by James Wood.28 City staff then met with Bourdon, and the City Attorney reported back: “The Developer, more or less, set standards that would guide the Board in imposing the mitigation requirements.”29 Martin, by then on the City’s Bay board himself, told the Planning Commission the buffer rules were “so onerous and costly and burdensome.”30 On April 28, 2009, Council adopted the version worked out with “developers, professionals, representatives of the Tidewater Builders Association,” with buffer replanting standards that “shall allow a lesser area of buffer restoration” whenever the owner shows a smaller one will do. The only ‘nay’ was Wood.27
The steering committee, 2011: Council creates it on May 24, 2011, with Dyer as its Council liaison, Bowie as chairman, and Martin as a member.15
Chesapeake Bay rules, 1990: Bowie, for the Tidewater Builders Association, asks for “the endorsement only of the watersheds which drain into the Chesapeake Bay,” leaving out Back Bay and the North Landing River. Council agrees, 11-0, on October 23, 1990.31
Stormwater, 1988: Bowie calls the City’s new stormwater ordinance a “stepchild” and asks that the builders help the City with “its implementation and its enforcement.”32
Trees, 1986: The City’s request for the power to protect trees “received much opposition most especially from the Virginia Home Builders Association” and is “stricken from the BILL” in Richmond.33
More cases are in Citizens v. Developers.
Notes and sources:
- City Council agenda, July 6, 2021, Item 5.a (ordinance to amend Sections 1-3 and 1-30 of Appendix D, Stormwater Appeals Board), PDF pages 44–45: email from Carrie L. Bookholt, Development Services Administrator, to Claudia Cotton, June 11, 2021, and Cotton’s reply, June 23, 2021. ↩
- Virginia Public Access Project, Coastal Va Building Industry Assn, contributions to Virginia Beach City Council and mayoral committees, 2007 to 2026, retrieved November 16, 2026: Rosemary Wilson $8,750, Bobby Dyer $8,000, Michael Berlucchi $3,000, Stacy Cummings $2,500, Joash Schulman $2,500, Worth Remick $1,500, David Hutcheson $1,000, and Cash Jackson-Green $1,000. The Coastal Virginia Building Industry Association (CVBIA) is the Tidewater Builders Association under a new name; its political action committee still files as the “Political Action Committee of Tidewater Builders Association,” 2117 Smith Avenue, Chesapeake. ↩
- City Council agenda, July 6, 2021, Item 5.a, staff summary, PDF pages 36–37. ↩
- City Council agenda, July 6, 2021, Item 5.a, “CVBIA comments,” PDF pages 44–46. Also copied: Kenneth Rodman Jr., Scott Acey, Greg Hayes (MSA), Jon Ettel, Bob Deacon, and Jonathan Speight. ↩
- City Council minutes, December 14, 2021, Item 72314 (Stormwater Regulatory Update briefing), PDF pages 16–18 and 23. ↩
- City Council minutes, March 1, 2022, Item 72554 (resolution to amend Chapter 8 of the Public Works Design Standards Manual, moved by Moss, seconded by Jones, 9-0; Holcomb and Wilson absent), PDF pages 46–48. Brad Martin spoke in opposition. ↩
- City Council minutes, February 1, 2022, Item 72469 (ordinance to amend Appendix D, Stormwater Management, re Stormwater Appeals Board, water quantity, appeals, and hearings), PDF pages 89–91; compare the July 6, 2021 draft, City Council agenda, July 6, 2021, Item 5.a, PDF page 38. Jones absent. ↩
- City Council special session minutes, June 23, 2020, Item 70433, PDF page 43; City Council minutes, April 15, 2025, Item 76933, PDF page 188. ↩
- City Council minutes, February 1, 2022, Item 72468 (resolution to amend Chapter 8, Stormwater Management, of the Public Works Design Standards Manual), PDF pages 36–37; Jones absent. The chapter as adopted checks “the higher of either 10-year+SLR or 100-year without SLR,” City Council minutes, February 1, 2022, PDF page 74. ↩
- Process Improvement Steering Committee, “Stormwater Solutions: A Stormwater Proposal,” January 2023, pages 3, 5, 7, and 8. The paper describes the City standard from about 1992 through 2014: a project “shall approximate ‘rate of flow’ AND ‘timing of runoff’ compared to existing.” ↩
- City Council minutes, May 3, 2022, Item 72818, PDF pages 159–160: Berlucchi, Linwood Branch, Dyer, Rocky Holcomb, Wilson, and Sabrina Wooten voted ‘aye’; Henley, Louis Jones, Moss, Aaron Rouse, and Tower voted ‘nay.’ ↩
- Brett Hall, “Virginia Beach City Council delays vote on flooding referendum promise,” WAVY, January 5, 2022. ↩
- City Council minutes, April 21, 2026, Item 78250, PDF pages 199–200. The ‘nays’ were Henley, Jackson-Green, and Jennifer Rouse. ↩
- City Council minutes, August 15, 2023, Item 74544 (Process Improvement Steering Committee update), PDF pages 2–5, including the committee’s FY 2023 annual report by Brad Martin, P.E., Chair, August 11, 2023. Members listed: Brad Martin (Chair), Tuck Bowie (Vice Chair), Billy Almond, Bill Coley, Larry Dotolo, Mike Eason, Tom Etter, Cal “Cash” Jackson-Green, Clenise Platt, and Sarah Welch. ↩
- City Council minutes, June 28, 2011, Item 61024, PDF pages 30–31 (Process Improvement Steering Committee contact list: “TUCK BOWIE-Chair,” tuckbow@terrypeterson.com; Brad Martin, brad@mart-eng.com; Bob Dyer, Council Liaison). Council created the committee on May 24, 2011, at the request of the Mayor, Vice Mayor, and Council Members Bellitto, Davis, DeSteph, Diezel, Dyer, Uhrin, Wilson, and Wood, City Council minutes, May 24, 2011, Item 60941, PDF page 19. ↩
- Virginia Department of Elections, Dyer Difference (committee CC-18-00247), report 403057: $4,000 from CVBIA, May 28, 2024. ↩
- City Council minutes, June 4, 2024, Item 75749, PDF pages 20–26 (resolution establishing the Stormwater Management Implementation Advisory Group, requested by Mayor Dyer and Council Member Schulman). ↩
- City Council minutes, June 18, 2024, Item 75843 (moved by Schulman, seconded by Jennifer Rouse), PDF page 75. ↩
- City Council minutes, July 2, 2024, Item 75926, PDF page 90 (Wilson nominated, three-year terms July 2, 2024 to June 30, 2027, 11-0). ↩
- Stormwater Management Implementation Advisory Group, minutes, May 2, 2025, pages 1–2, and member list, 2025. Pocta, of Wolcott Rivers Gates, represented Harrison and Lear before the Planning Commission in February 2026. ↩
- Stormwater Management Implementation Advisory Group, Recommendations, November 10, 2025, pages 4–5. ↩
- City Council minutes, August 19, 2025, Item 77445 (ordinance to amend Appendix F, Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area Ordinance), PDF pages 173–174. ↩
- City Council agenda, August 19, 2025, Item J.4, staff summary, PDF pages 58–59; City Council minutes, August 12, 2025, planning briefing, PDF pages 112–114 (“Briefings to various boards/commissions (CBPA Board, Green Ribbon Committee, Planning Commission, Coastal Virginia Building Industry Association)”; “No known opposition”). ↩
- City Council minutes, December 9, 2003, Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area Ordinance, Section 101, PDF pages 185–186 (the wording in force before 2025); the same sentences are struck through in the 2025 ordinance, City Council minutes, August 19, 2025, Item 77445, PDF page 174. ↩
- City Code § 2-3, as quoted in City Council minutes, October 3, 2017, Item 67466, PDF pages 74–75. ↩
- City Council minutes, June 16, 2015, Item 64979, PDF page 111 (Martin appointed on Henley’s nomination, “No term,” 9-0). The committee’s seats had no set terms until May 7, 2024, City Council minutes, May 7, 2024, Item 75644, PDF pages 42–43. ↩
- City Council minutes, April 28, 2009, Item 58764 (ordinance to amend the Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area Ordinance re swimming pools and uniform buffer restoration standards), PDF pages 104–109: moved by Vice Mayor Jones, seconded by Dyer, 10-1; staff summary at PDF page 109. ↩
- City Council minutes, August 26, 2008, Item 57954, PDF page 94. ↩
- City Council minutes, February 3, 2009, Item 58496, PDF page 22 (clerk’s summary of Acting City Attorney Bill Macali). ↩
- Planning Commission transcript, April 8, 2009, Item 25 (City of Virginia Beach, Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area Ordinance), in City Council agenda, April 28, 2009, PDF pages 266–267. ↩
- City Council minutes, October 23, 1990, Item 33628, PDF pages 50–53 (clerk’s summary). The full story is in Citizens v. Developers. ↩
- City Council minutes, April 18, 1988, Item 29219, PDF page 24 (clerk’s summary). ↩
- City Council minutes, March 10, 1986, Item 25079, PDF page 79. ↩
Last updated November 21, 2026.
Have records or evidence about this? Email keepvbabovewater@gmail.com.

Leave a Reply