Stacy Cummings:  District 8 Councilman Who Seats His Donors on the Wetlands Board

Flowchart: how builders, developers, and their money connect to Councilman Stacy Cummings and his votes

Retired car salesman Stacy Cummings has done more damage to District 8 in two years than most accomplish in twenty.1

A liaison to the Military Economic Development Advisory Committee, Cummings voted to give VB National to Dragas, seated two builders on the Wetlands Board (after they gave him $30,000), and never missed an ‘aye’ when Dear Eddie appeared before him.2

Last updated November 20, 2026.

Flowchart: how builders, developers, and their money connect to Councilman Stacy Cummings and his votes
Gold lines are money.  Red lines are votes.

Standing conflicts:
Still standing today

  • Builders he seated on the Wetlands Board pay him.  Stephen Ballard and S.B. Ballard Construction have given Cummings $16,000, and Jeffrey and John Ainslie and the Ainslie Group $14,000.  Details
  • Developers’ money, developers’ votes.  Atlantic Park’s Venture Realty team ($19,500), Franklin Group ($19,000), Michael Sifen ($10,000), Dragas ($7,500), and Cheryl McLeskey ($3,500) all had votes in front of him.  Dragas, Franklin, McLeskey, Others
  • Quieter public hearings.  A week after the VB National vote, Cummings asked Council to ban audience noise for the entire meeting, not just while a speaker has the floor.  Details

Cummings’s Wetlands Board:  $30,000 from two builders

The Wetlands Board decides who may fill or dig in tidal wetlands.  Council appoints its members.3  Cummings voted ‘aye’ to seat two builders who pay his campaigns.

  • April 18 and August 9, 2024:  S.B. Ballard Construction gives Cummings $1,000 and $5,000.
  • September 16, 2025:  Cummings votes ‘aye’, 11-0, to reappoint builder Stephen B. Ballard to the Wetlands Board for five years.4
  • December 2, 2025:  Cummings votes ‘aye’, 10-0, to reappoint Ballard to the Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area Board, too.5
  • February 17, 2026:  Cummings votes ‘aye’, 10-0, to seat builder Jeffrey Ainslie (Ainslie Group) on the Wetlands Board.  Ainslie gave Cummings $10,000 on May 16, 2024.6
  • April 9, 2026:  51 days later, Ainslie gives Cummings $2,500, and S.B. Ballard Construction gives $5,000.
  • September 8 and 10, 2026:  Stephen Ballard gives Cummings $5,000, and John Ainslie (Ainslie Group) gives $1,000.7

Wetlands:  Six ‘aye’ votes, 100 acres

Since January 2025, Cummings has voted ‘aye’ six times to develop sites holding 100.11 acres of wetlands afforded the greatest protection under state law.89

  • VB National (Dragas), 53.26 acres:  August 11, 2026, 9-2.10
  • Bonney Bright borrow pit, 29.59 acres:  March 18, 2025, 10-0.11
  • Dam Neck Associates (Franklin Johnston affiliate), 10.17 acres:  March 4, 2025, 9-0.12
  • Starling BESS battery plant (3.88), Foodbank warehouse (1.84), and 2501 Holland Road (1.37):  July 8, June 17, and August 19, 2025.13

Dragas:  $7,500, then VB National

  • April 18 and August 19, 2024:  Dragas companies give candidate Cummings $2,500, then $5,000, while the City negotiates VB National with Helen Dragas in private.14
  • June 10 and July 8, 2025:  Cummings votes ‘aye’, 11-0, to go into closed session on publicly-held property in “District 2.”  Neither motion names the golf course.15
  • August 11, 2026:  Cummings votes ‘nay’ on Barbara Henley’s motion to delay 90 days, then ‘aye’ to give 341.4 acres of public land at VB National to Dragas, 9-2.10A  The deal adds $1,820,000 from the VBDA,B $4,300,000 for roads and utilities,C up to $3,600,000 for cost overruns,D and a “performance grant” of up to $10,200,000.E  Residents keep the liability.

One week later:  Quiet the crowd

On August 18, 2026, Mayor Bobby Dyer reads a new rule against clapping, booing, or other sounds while a speaker has the floor.  Cummings says a friend who spoke for the golf course deal “was intimidated by the crowd,” that “there is a small group who attend to cause a disruption regardless of the topic,” and asks that the ban “apply throughout the entire proceeding.”  The City Attorney cautions that this “could be difficult” and that both sides must be treated equally.16

Franklin Group:  $19,000

  • March 22, 2024:  The Franklin Johnston Group gives candidate Cummings $5,000.
  • July 8, 2025:  More than 20 residents and civic leagues speak against Franklin’s Silo at Southern Pine apartments on farmland next to VB National.  Cummings votes ‘nay’ on Henley’s motion to deny, then ‘aye’ to approve, 9-2.17
  • October 21, 2025:  Cummings votes ‘aye’, 11-0, on a workforce housing grant to The Silo Apartments, paying back its new real estate taxes, $216,179 the first year, for 30 years.18
  • April 9, September 10, and October 22, 2026:  Franklin Group Companies gives $5,000, Wendell Franklin $2,500, and Taylor Franklin $6,500.19

McLeskey:  $1,000, 16 days after $2.66 million

  • April 25, 2024:  Cheryl McLeskey gives candidate Cummings $2,500.
  • January 7, 2025:  Cummings votes ‘aye’, 10-0, to move $6,660,143 from beach replenishment and Rudee Inlet work into the Pleasure House Point wetlands mitigation bank, which clears maritime forest in the park McLeskey’s Shore Drive land borders.20
  • April 7, 2026:  Cummings votes ‘aye’, 10-0, to pay McLeskey’s Riverwalk, LLC $2,662,500 for five vacant lots, 0.57 acres, on Crab Creek.  The City’s own assessor valued them at $152,000.21
  • April 23, 2026:  16 days later, McLeskey gives Cummings $1,000.22

Bonney Road:  The Petersons’ $1,000

  • September 29, 2026:  John H. Peterson III’s J&L Property Holdings gives Cummings $1,000.  J&L Bonney Rd Apmts LLC is a member of the applicant, and Tuck Bowie brings the project.23
  • October 20, 2026:  21 days later, Cummings votes ‘aye’, 10-0, by consent, to rezone 4576 Bonney Road from industrial to 209 apartments.  Lisa Murphy is the attorney.24

The builders’ trade group:  $1,500, five days before

On September 10, 2026, the Coastal Virginia Building Industry Association gives Cummings $1,500.  Five days later, on September 15, he votes ‘aye’ on Bonaventure’s 251 apartments at the Back Bay Farmhouse, 9-1, over a petition with 6,556 signatures.25

Henley’s motions:  ‘Nay’, then ‘aye’

Cummings votes ‘nay’ on Henley’s motions to deny the Silo (July 8, 2025), to delay the new Comprehensive Plan, imagine VB2040, 60 days (April 21, 2026), and to delay VB National 90 days (August 11, 2026).  Each time, he then votes ‘aye’ to approve.26

Cummings’s appointments:  Donors and a third term

  • April 1, 2025:  Cummings votes ‘aye’, 11-0, to seat Edward Amorosso (BDO, CPA) on the Bayfront Advisory Commission.  Amorosso gave him $2,500 in 2024 and $2,500 more in 2026.  Gregory Amorosso, CPA for Cummings’s Priority Auto, gave $1,000.27
  • August 19, 2025:  Cummings votes ‘aye’ to give Lisa Murphy a third four-year term on the VBDA.  City Code § 2-3 limits board members to two consecutive full terms unless Council makes a stated finding, and the minutes contain no such finding.28
  • September 2, 2025:  Cummings votes ‘aye’, 11-0, to reappoint MEB Vice President Eric Keplinger to the VBDA.  Keplinger gives him $1,000 on May 7, 2026.29
  • September 2, 2025:  Cummings votes ‘aye’, 10-1, to name Neptune’s Park after former Mayor Will Sessoms.  Sessoms gives him $500 on April 9, 2026.30
  • August 18, 2026:  Cummings votes ‘aye’ to reappoint William Brunke to the VBDA, whose CPA firm files Rosemary Wilson’s campaign reports.31

Other developers’ money

  • Atlantic Park team, $19,500:  Venture Realty Group’s Douglas Ellis ($10,000), John Gibson ($6,000), Donna Whitaker ($2,500), and Bruce Berlin ($1,000).  On April 1, 2025, Cummings votes ‘aye’ on the Venture Waves valet franchise at Atlantic Park, 11-0.  Ellis gives him $5,000 on January 29, 2026, 40 days before the VBDA settles with Venture Waves for $8 million plus land.32
  • Michael Sifen, $10,000:  On January 20, 2026, Cummings votes ‘aye’, 10-0, on Sifen’s mini-warehouse at 1120 First Colonial Road.  35 days later, on February 24, Sifen gives him $5,000.33
  • The Cavalier, $1,500:  Bruce L. Thompson (Gold Key | PHR) gives candidate Cummings $1,500 on April 8, 2024.  On April 1, 2025, Cummings votes ‘aye’ on the Cavalier beach franchise agreement, 11-0.34

Taken from the public:

  1. $10,689,300 in public land to Helen Dragas.  Council gave Dragas 341.4 acres at VB National assessed at $10,689,300.  The $17,940,000 price is paid back to Dragas for golf course work, so the City keeps nothing for the land.  City Council minutes, August 11, 2026, Item K.1 (ordinance and term sheet § 3), PDF pages 97–98 and 105–106; City Real Estate Assessor, FY 2026/27 assessments, GPINs 1494-34-4919, 1494-52-3434, 1494-13-7202, and 1494-03-5237.  Running total:  $10,689,300.  ↩
  2. $1,820,000 from the VBDA to Helen Dragas.  City Council minutes, August 11, 2026, Item K.1 (term sheet), PDF pages 103, 107, and 108.  Running total:  $12,509,300.  ↩
  3. $4,300,000 from the City to Helen Dragas for roads, sewer, and utilities.  Each reimbursed cost carries a 10% fee to Dragas Management Corporation.  City Council minutes, August 11, 2026, Item K.1 (term sheet), PDF pages 103, 106, 107, and 108.  Running total:  $16,809,300.  ↩
  4. Up to $3,600,000 to Helen Dragas for cost overruns.  City Council minutes, August 11, 2026, Item K.1 (term sheet), PDF pages 103, 107, and 108.  Running total:  $16,809,300, plus up to $3,600,000.  ↩
  5. Up to $10,200,000 to Helen Dragas in a “performance grant,” adjusted for inflation, from the property’s new real estate taxes.  City Council minutes, August 11, 2026, Item K.1 (term sheet § 10(a)), PDF pages 110–111.  Running total:  $16,809,300, plus up to $13,800,000.  ↩

Total in this post:  $16,809,300, plus up to $13,800,000 more promised.  Total owed to the public, all posts:  $17,831,669 plus up to $13,800,000.

Notes and sources:

  1. Cummings is a retired founding partner and chief financial officer of Priority Auto Group.  He won a special election on November 5, 2024, took office in January 2025, and was re-elected on November 3, 2026.  Ballotpedia, Stacy Cummings Jr.; WAVY, candidate profile, Stacy Cummings Jr., Virginia Beach City Council; Princess Anne Independent, “Elections:  Dyer wins in crowded field to remain Virginia Beach mayor on strong day for City Council incumbents,” November 2026.  ↩
  2. Builders Stephen Ballard and S.B. Ballard Construction ($16,000) and Jeffrey and John Ainslie and the Ainslie Group ($14,000).  Cummings has voted for Eddie Bourdon’s clients 28 times without a single ‘nay’.  KVBAW Votes and Conflicts Log, Wetlands tally, Board_Appointee_Gifts, and Votes_vs_Money tabs, built from City Council minutes, January 2025 to October 2026.  ↩
  3. Code of Virginia §§ 28.2-1302 and 28.2-1303.  ↩
  4. City Council minutes, September 16, 2025, Item 77569, PDF page 140.  ↩
  5. City Council minutes, December 2, 2025, Item 77821, PDF page 73.  ↩
  6. City Council minutes, February 17, 2026, Item 78035, PDF page 112.  ↩
  7. Virginia Department of Elections, Friends of Stacy Cummings (CC-23-02493), reports 407648, 413589, 496417, and 508891.  ↩
  8. Code of Virginia § 28.2-1308(B)(3); filling wetlands also requires permits under the Clean Water Act, 33 U.S.C. § 1344, and Code of Virginia § 62.1-44.15:20.  ↩
  9. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service National Wetlands Inventory map, measured on each application’s site.  KVBAW Votes and Conflicts Log, Wetlands fill tab.  ↩
  10. City Council minutes, August 11, 2026, Item K.1, PDF page 97.  ↩
  11. City Council minutes, March 18, 2025, Item 76804, PDF pages 124 to 127.  ↩
  12. City Council minutes, March 4, 2025, Item 76742, PDF page 95; City Council agenda packet, March 4, 2025, applicant disclosure statement.  ↩
  13. City Council minutes, July 8, 2025, Items 77361 and 77362, PDF pages 207 to 209; August 19, 2025, Item 77446, PDF page 217; June 17, 2025, Item 2025-PCCC-00024.  ↩
  14. Dragas City Ties; Virginia Department of Elections, Friends of Stacy Cummings (CC-23-02493), reports 407648 and 413589.  ↩
  15. City Council minutes, closed-session motions, June 10, 2025, Item 77229, PDF pages 66–67; July 8, 2025, Item 77343, PDF pages 115–116.  ↩
  16. City Council minutes, August 18, 2026, City Council Discussion/Initiatives/Comments, PDF pages 29 and 30.  ↩
  17. City Council minutes, July 8, 2025, Items 77355 to 77357, PDF pages 153 and 154.  ↩
  18. City Council minutes, October 21, 2025, Items 77678 and 77679, PDF pages 129 to 133; VBDA minutes, October 14, 2025.  ↩
  19. Virginia Department of Elections, Friends of Stacy Cummings (CC-23-02493), reports 407648, 496417, 508891, and 511695; The Franklin Group.  ↩
  20. City Council minutes, January 7, 2025, Item 76529, PDF pages 42 to 43.  ↩
  21. City Council minutes, April 7, 2026, Item 78177, PDF pages 117 to 119; City of Virginia Beach Real Estate Assessor, FY2026 assessments, GPINs 1489-57-5736, 1489-57-5811, 1489-57-5835, 1489-57-5895, and 1489-57-6847.  ↩
  22. Virginia Department of Elections, Friends of Stacy Cummings (CC-23-02493), reports 407648 and 496417.  ↩
  23. Virginia Department of Elections, J&L Property Holdings, LLC to Friends of Stacy Cummings, September 29, 2026, report 508891; City Council agenda, October 20, 2026, Item L.7, disclosure statement; Tuck Bowie.  ↩
  24. City Council minutes, October 20, 2026, Item L.7, PDF page 99.  ↩
  25. City Council minutes, September 15, 2026, Item K.2, PDF pages 104–105; Virginia Department of Elections, Tidewater Builders Association PAC to Friends of Stacy Cummings, September 27, 2024, report 417265, and September 10, 2026, report 508891; Citizens v. Developers.  ↩
  26. City Council minutes, July 8, 2025, Items 77355 to 77357, PDF pages 153 and 154; April 21, 2026, Item 78250, PDF pages 199 and 200; August 11, 2026, Item K.1, PDF page 97.  ↩
  27. City Council minutes, April 1, 2025, Item 76868, PDF page 212; Virginia Department of Elections, Friends of Stacy Cummings, reports 407648, 496417, and 506161.  ↩
  28. City Council minutes, August 19, 2025, Item 77453, PDF page 249; Virginia Beach City Code § 2-3(a) and (b).  ↩
  29. City Council minutes, September 2, 2025, Item 77498, PDF page 180; Friends of Stacy Cummings, report 496417; MEB General Contractors.  ↩
  30. City Council minutes, September 2, 2025, Item 77475, PDF page 97; Friends of Stacy Cummings, report 496417.  ↩
  31. City Council minutes, August 18, 2026, Appointments, PDF page 107.  ↩
  32. City Council minutes, April 1, 2025, Item 76859; VBDA minutes, March 10, 2026; Virginia Department of Elections, Friends of Stacy Cummings, reports 407648, 413589, 484378, and 496417.  ↩
  33. City Council minutes, January 20, 2026, Item 77930, PDF pages 126 and 127; Friends of Stacy Cummings, reports 420451 and 484378.  ↩
  34. City Council minutes, April 1, 2025, Item 76858, PDF page 170; Friends of Stacy Cummings, report 407648.  ↩

Last updated November 20, 2026.

Have records or evidence about this?  Email keepvbabovewater@gmail.com.

Comments

Leave a Reply