The Back Bay Farmhouse:  6,556 Signatures, Nine ‘Aye’ Votes

Back Bay Farmhouse connections

The Back Bay Farmhouse at 1805 Kempsville Road was built as a Wood family home about 1912, became the office of the family’s real estate business on land zoned for offices, and then became a brewery where neighbors gathered.  On September 15, 2026, Council voted 9-1 to put 251 apartments in two four-story buildings around it, over 6,556 petition signatures and four civic leagues.1, 2

The biggest conflict:  Seven of the nine ‘aye’ votes took Bonaventure money

The developer, Bonaventure, and its people have given $17,750 to the seven Council members who voted ‘aye’ and are still serving.  Two of those gifts, from Bonaventure’s Ben Flood, came in June 2026, after the family and Bonaventure signed the proffers and before the Planning Commission heard the case.3

Standing conflicts:
Still standing today

  • Mayor Bobby Dyer:  $10,000 from Bonaventure Realty Group, then ‘aye.’  Before the vote, he told residents, “I’ve worked with Bonaventure before.”4  He also took $1,000 from Edward Hewitt, a Lillel Farms officer, on August 31, 2020.5
  • Vice Mayor Rosemary Wilson:  $3,250 from Bonaventure, then ‘aye.’
  • Michael Berlucchi:  $2,250 from Bonaventure, then ‘aye.’
  • Cash Jackson-Green:  $1,000 from Breanna Berry of Bonaventure on June 4, 2025, then made the motion to approve.
  • Worth Remick:  $500 from Ben Flood on June 17, 2026, and $1,500 from the builders’ trade group on September 3, 2026, then ‘aye.’6
  • Joash Schulman:  $500 from Ben Flood on June 24, 2026, then argued against giving residents 30 more days.  The builders’ trade group gave him $1,500 on the day of the vote, and he voted ‘aye.’6
  • Stacy Cummings:  $1,500 from the builders’ trade group five days before the vote, then ‘aye.’6
  • Amelia Ross-Hammond:  ‘aye,’ then $250 from Ben Flood 36 days later.
Back Bay Farmhouse connections
The Back Bay Farmhouse:  who got what.

The land:  The Wood family keeps a stake

William Elliott Wood bought the land in 1910 and built the farmhouse about two years later.  His son, William E. Wood Jr., started the real estate company William E. Wood and Associates.7  Today the land belongs to The Farmhouse, LLC, whose managers, Sara W. Will and Shauna Firman, signed the proffers with Bonaventure’s BH Farmhouse, LLC on March 30, 2026.8  The family company, Lillel Farms, Inc., lists W. Vincent Wood, Sara W. Hewitt, Anne D. Wood, Edward Hewitt, and Shauna T. Firman as officers.9  This is not former Councilman Jim Wood’s family.

The family is not simply selling.  Asked at the Planning Commission whether the Woods were “a partner in this with you,” Bonaventure’s attorney, Rob Beaman, answered:  “That’s absolutely correct.  They are remaining involved in the ownership group.”10  Shauna Firman told Council it is “the fourth partnership between the two families.”11

The developer:  Bonaventure

Bonaventure, of Alexandria, builds apartments under the “Attain” name.  The Wood family’s Lillel Farms is listed as a member of Bonaventure’s Cascades at Woods Corner apartment companies, and Council has rezoned Woods Corner land for Bonaventure again and again.12  Its Chic’s Beach project, Windsong, needed a brand-new A-36 apartment district that the City Zoning Ordinance says is not meant to be created.13  Ben Flood, who spoke for Bonaventure, described the company this way:  “We don’t just build and sell.”14

Bonaventure’s Virginia Beach apartments around the Farmhouse:

  • The Cascades, Centerville Turnpike and Lynnhaven Parkway:  rezoned for Bonaventure in 2008 and 2012; the Wood family’s Lillel Farms is listed as a member of the Cascades company.12
  • Infinity at Centerville Crossing:  built on 10.36 acres of Lillel Farms land, a plat the family titled “Infinity Subdivision of Parcel A, Property of Lillel Farms, Inc.”  The land came to Lillel Farms from William E. Wood Jr. and Anne Wood in 1973.  Council approved Bonaventure’s changes as BRG Cascades East, LLC on July 5, 2016, 8-0.15
  • Magnolia Run (200 units, built 2002) and Magnolia Chase (185 units, built 1999):  Bonaventure did not build these; it bought them in December 2021 and September 2022.16
  • Windsong, Chic’s Beach:  now “Attain at Chic’s Beach,” after Council created a new A-36 district for it, 7-4.13

The “shopping center” threat:  Council created it

The argument that won the vote was fear of something worse.  The land is zoned B-2 commercial, so a shopping center could go there without a vote.  Planning Commissioner Walter Camp said a commercial project “would generate nineteen hundred more daily car trips per day” and added, “Now that doesn’t mean I love what they’re proposing.”17  Schulman told residents, “what they can do by right would be far worse.”18  The Wood family’s Eddie Hewitt said, “It would be far easier to tear down the farmhouse and build a shopping center.”19

That B-2 zoning came from Council.  On June 7, 2016, on a motion by Louis Jones, seconded by Dyer, Council rezoned 1805 Kempsville Road from O-2 Office to Conditional B-2 Community Business, with permits for a craft brewery, events, and an open-air market, 11-0, by consent.  Dyer, Henley, Ross-Hammond, and Wilson are still on Council.20  On June 22, 2016, the VBDA gave Back Bay Brewing a $35,000 grant to move into the farmhouse.A, 21  On July 13, 2016, 36 days after Council’s vote, Back Bay Brewing gave Mayor Will Sessoms’s campaign $1,000 in event expenses.22

Even Camp said the plan for this spot did not call for housing:  “My concern is that the Strategic Growth Area Plan calls for this to be commercial, not housing.”  He voted ‘aye’ anyway, “because of what would happen if this is not approved.”23

What Council waived

  • Lot width:  200 feet required; 50.26 feet approved.24
  • Setback on Luck Lane:  35 feet required; 15 feet approved.8
  • Setback on Kempsville Road:  15 feet required; 10 feet approved.8
  • Parking:  463 spaces required; 388 approved, on the theory that residents will walk, bike, and ride the bus.25
  • Density:  29.42 units an acre, next to one- and two-story homes.24

Where the water goes

The site drains toward Stumpy Lake.26  The site is in the North Landing River watershed, which flows south to Albemarle Sound, not to the Chesapeake Bay.27  It is one of the watersheds the builders’ trade group, through Tuck Bowie, asked Council in 1990 to keep out of the new Chesapeake Bay rules.28  The FEMA flood map shows the lot itself in Zone X, and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service National Wetlands Inventory map shows no wetlands on it.29  The trouble is downstream.

Danielle Swartz, the Brigadoon Civic League’s president, told Council the neighborhood “surrounds Stumpy Lake” and already has drainage problems, with a $4 million retention pond planned nearby:  “If we’re already planning a retention pond for the current conditions, it will only get worse.”30  No stormwater plan was in front of anyone who voted.  Planning Commissioner Susan Hippen said Bonaventure “will have to do a stormwater plan that will come later in the process.”  When Lake James asked to have a say in it, City staff answered:  “There’s not necessarily input that you can provide.”26

Claims vs. reality

Jackson-Green’s claim vs. reality

August 11, 2026:  “So, mayor, I have successfully negotiated for the farmhouse, historic farmhouse to be preserved.”31

The record:  In March, before any application was filed, Bonaventure’s JP Hyland said keeping the farmhouse “was a non-negotiable condition” of the Wood family.32  The family’s spokeswoman told Council the same thing:  “First, the farmhouse has to be preserved.”11

Schulman’s claim vs. reality

August 11, 2026:  “The stormwater I would suppose would be in a better situation after the redevelopment.”33

The record:  No stormwater plan existed.  The Planning Commission was told the plan “will come later in the process.”26

In their own words

  • Schulman, arguing against a 30-day delay to settle who pays for the crossing signal:  “I think that’s kind of hiding the ball a little red herring.”34  Bonaventure had offered $100,000 toward a signal that costs about $600,000.  City Manager Patrick Duhaney:  “$100,000 just does just doesn’t do it.  And in order for us to fully cover cost, it means we’ll be taken from another project somewhere else in the city.”35  Bonaventure raised its offer to $600,000 only after the delay passed.36
  • Jackson-Green, moving to approve after residents asked for time:  “I don’t think 30 days from now is going to solve the issue.  If they don’t want it then I mean what are we going to do?”37
  • Jackson-Green, on September 15:  “So don’t feel defeated because there are profers in this agreement.”38
  • Dyer, on August 11:  “I like this project.  A lot of people have objections to, but . . . I’ve worked with Bonaventure before.”4  On September 15:  “We cannot ignore a crisis and housing is a crisis.”39
  • David Hutcheson, on August 11:  “To be good stewards of the taxpayers’ dollars, which I know is up for question tonight . . . .”40  He seconded the approval on September 15.1
  • Rob Beaman, Bonaventure’s attorney, on the crossing signal at the Planning Commission:  “If that’s something the city wants, that’s something that we’re, we’re willing to do.”41

What residents said

The petition started March 22, 2026 and had 6,556 signatures by the Planning Commission hearing.42, 2  The Brigadoon, Charlestowne Area, Brandon, and Lake South civic leagues spoke against it.1, 30

  • Danielle Swartz, Brigadoon Civic League president:  “In conversations with some city officials we have spoken with, we have been left with the impression that the deal is already done.  The vote hasn’t even been cast.”43
  • Samantha Roaquin, Charlestowne Area Civic League president:  “Bonaventure agreed to give the city of Virginia Beach $100,000 . . . .  But just alone, a [HAWK] signal is 600,000.”44
  • Melanie Fitzgerald, Brandon Civic League secretary:  “Please don’t take away one of the only green spaces attached to our neighborhood.”45
  • A Lake South Civic League representative:  “If you have run on transparency . . . and you have received donations from Bonaventure, I hope you will consider uh refraining from voting on this issue tonight.”46  No one did.

Timeline

  • June 4, 2025:  Breanna Berry ($1,000, Bonaventure) gives to Jackson-Green.
  • March 22, 2026:  Residents start the petition.42
  • March 30, 2026:  BH Farmhouse and The Farmhouse, LLC sign the proffers.8
  • June 17 and 24, 2026:  Ben Flood ($500 each, Bonaventure) gives to Remick and Schulman.
  • July 8, 2026:  The Planning Commission recommends approval, 11-0, on Katherine Schoonover’s motion and Kathryn Byler’s second.23
  • August 11, 2026:  Jackson-Green moves to approve, and Hutcheson seconds.  Hutcheson then moves to defer 30 days over the crossing signal money; Schulman argues against waiting.  The deferral passes 10-1.47
  • September 3, 10, and 15, 2026:  The builders’ trade group gives Remick, Cummings, and Schulman $1,500 each, Schulman’s on the day of the vote.6
  • September 15, 2026:  Jackson-Green moves to approve, and Hutcheson seconds.  Berlucchi, Cummings, Dyer, Hutcheson, Jackson-Green, Remick, Ross-Hammond, Schulman, and Wilson vote ‘aye.’  Barbara Henley votes ‘nay.’  Jennifer Rouse is absent.1
  • October 21, 2026:  Benjamin Flood ($250, Bonaventure) gives to Ross-Hammond.

The money:  Bonaventure gifts to Council members who voted ‘aye’

Council memberTotalGifts
Bobby Dyer$10,000August 14, 2018, $2,500; September 15, 2020, $2,000; September 18, 2020, $1,000; September 10, 2021, $1,000; October 11, 2021, $1,000; May 3, 2024, $1,000; March 25, 2025, $1,500 (all Bonaventure Realty Group)48
Rosemary Wilson$3,250September 30, 2019, $2,000 (Bonaventure Wealth Fund); October 16, 2020, $1,000 (Bonaventure Realty Group); September 26, 2024, $250 (Nolan Dee, Bonaventure)49
Michael Berlucchi$2,250September 22, 2019, $1,000 (Bonaventure Wealth Fund); October 9, 2020, $1,000 (Bonaventure); September 24, 2024, $250 (Bonaventure)50
Cash Jackson-Green$1,000June 4, 2025, $1,000 (Breanna Berry, Bonaventure Property Co)51
Worth Remick$500June 17, 2026, $500 (Benjamin Flood, Bonaventure)52
Joash Schulman$500June 24, 2026, $500 (Ben Flood, Bonaventure)53
Amelia Ross-Hammond$250October 21, 2026, $250 (Benjamin Flood, Bonaventure)54
Total$17,750

Virginia Beach legislators

  • Sen. Bill DeSteph:  As a Council member, he seconded Bonaventure’s first Virginia Beach rezoning at Woods Corner on February 12, 2008.  Bonaventure gave his delegate campaign $2,000 on June 17, 2013, 99 days before Council rezoned the Wood family’s Lillel Farms land for Bonaventure.12, 55

Before 2018

  • 1981 and 1984:  Tuck Bowie represents Woods Corner Associates, Ltd. and Lillel Corporation before Council.  In 1988, the partnership that owns the Woods Corner shopping center names Breck-N-Bill, Ltd., at 1805 Kempsville Road, as a managing partner.  More in Tuck Bowie.56
  • February 12, 2008:  Bonaventure’s Cascades at Woods Corner swaps most of its approved shops for more apartments.  Dyer moves, DeSteph seconds, and it passes 7-3.  Henley calls the mixed use “token.”12
  • September 11, 2012:  Council lets the Cascades “replace the retail uses with residential units,” 11-0, by consent.12
  • September 24, 2013:  Council rezones Lillel Farms’ land at 2120 Centerville Turnpike from business to apartments, 11-0, by consent, with Bonaventure Realty Group listed for development services.9, 12
  • June 7, 2016:  Council rezones the farmhouse from office to commercial B-2, 11-0.20

In the news

  • “Apartments proposed for Back Bay Farmhouse Brewing land in Virginia Beach,” WTKR, March 2026
  • “Planning Commission backs apartment project at Back Bay’s Farmhouse site,” WTKR, July 2026
  • “Apartment plan in Virginia Beach faces opposition, but has planning commission backing,” WHRO, August 10, 2026
  • “Back Bay’s Farmhouse redevelopment vote delayed over traffic signal concerns,” WTKR, August 2026
  • “Virginia Beach council clears path for apartments at Farmhouse brewery site,” WHRO, September 16, 2026

Taken from the public:

  1. $35,000 VBDA grant to Back Bay Brewing (owner Josh Canada), June 22, 2016, to move the brewery into the Wood family farmhouse; the Wood family’s Eddie Hewitt became a partner later that year.  “Back Bay Brewing nabs city grant for expansion to Virginia Beach farmhouse,” WYDaily, June 22, 2016.  Running total:  $35,000.  ↩

Total in this post:  $35,000.

Notes and sources:

  1. City Council minutes, September 15, 2026, Item K.2, BH Farmhouse, LLC/The Farmhouse LLC, PDF pages 104–105.  ↩
  2. Planning Commission minutes, July 8, 2026, Items 6 and 7, BH Farmhouse, LLC, PDF pages 16–36 (verbatim); the 6,556 count is Samantha Roaquin’s, PDF page 22.  ↩
  3. Virginia Department of Elections campaign finance reports listed in “The money” table below.  ↩
  4. City Council meeting video, August 11, 2026, Item L.1, at 6:27:19.  ↩
  5. Virginia Department of Elections, Dyer Difference, report 218198 (Edward Hewitt, Viridian Homes, August 31, 2020, $1,000).  ↩
  6. Virginia Public Access Project, Coastal Va Building Industry Assn, contributions to Remick (September 3, 2026), Cummings (September 10, 2026), and Schulman (September 15, 2026), $1,500 each.  ↩
  7. “Farmhouse Brewing Co. to open Sept. 29.  Here’s the plan and the story behind the farmhouse,” WYDaily, August 28, 2018.  ↩
  8. City Council minutes, September 15, 2026, Item K.2, proffer agreement dated March 30, 2026, PDF pages 107–112.  ↩
  9. City Council agenda, September 24, 2013, Lillel Farms, Inc. disclosure, PDF pages 243–244.  ↩
  10. Planning Commission minutes, July 8, 2026, Items 6 and 7, PDF page 34.  ↩
  11. City Council meeting video, September 15, 2026, Item K.2, at 2:52:35.  ↩
  12. City Council minutes, February 12, 2008, Item 57330, PDF pages 100–102; September 11, 2012, Item 62208, PDF pages 25 and 93; September 24, 2013, Item 63133, PDF page 35; City Council agenda, September 11, 2012, BPMS Cascades disclosure, PDF page 150.  ↩
  13. City Council minutes, January 19, 2021 special session, Item 71216, PDF pages 73–75; Virginia Beach City Zoning Ordinance § 600.  ↩
  14. City Council meeting video, September 15, 2026, Item K.2, at 3:02:06.  ↩
  15. City Council minutes, June 21, 2016, BRG Cascades East, LLC, legal description, PDF page 164 (plat dated October 24, 2014, instrument 20141209001156990; deed book 1395, page 476); City Council summary of actions, July 5, 2016, PDF page 168.  ↩
  16. “Bonaventure Expands Va. Multifamily Portfolio with Acquisition of Messenger Place Manassas and Magnolia Run Virginia Beach,” Business Wire, December 20, 2021; “Bonaventure Acquires Two Multifamily Properties in UPREIT Transactions,” Business Wire, September 16, 2022.  ↩
  17. Planning Commission minutes, July 8, 2026, Items 6 and 7, PDF page 23.  ↩
  18. City Council meeting video, August 11, 2026, Item L.1, at 6:13:02.  ↩
  19. City Council meeting video, September 15, 2026, Item K.2, at 2:50:16.  ↩
  20. City Council minutes, June 7, 2016, Item 66039 (Item VII-K.7), Farmhouse, LLC, PDF pages 138–140.  ↩
  21. “Back Bay Brewing nabs city grant for expansion to Virginia Beach farmhouse,” WYDaily, June 22, 2016 (Economic Development Incentive Program grant from the Virginia Beach Development Authority, $1.4 million project).  ↩
  22. Virginia Department of Elections, W.D. “Will” Sessoms for Mayor, report 99452, Schedule B (in-kind), Back Bay Brewing Company, July 13, 2016, $1,000, “Event expense”.  ↩
  23. Planning Commission minutes, July 8, 2026, Items 6 and 7, PDF page 36.  ↩
  24. City Council minutes, August 11, 2026, City Manager’s briefing on pending planning items, PDF pages 17–20.  ↩
  25. Planning Commission minutes, July 8, 2026, Items 6 and 7, PDF page 26 (Caitlin Trist, citing the staff report).  ↩
  26. Planning Commission minutes, July 8, 2026, Items 6 and 7, PDF page 19.  ↩
  27. U.S. Geological Survey, Watershed Boundary Dataset:  1805 Kempsville Road falls in HUC-12 030102051201 (Chesapeake Canal), HUC-10 0301020512 (North Landing River), subbasin 03010205 (Albemarle).  ↩
  28. City Council minutes, October 23, 1990, Item 33628, PDF pages 50–53.  ↩
  29. FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, 1805 Kempsville Road:  Zone X, area of minimal flood hazard; U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service National Wetlands Inventory map.  ↩
  30. City Council meeting video, August 11, 2026, Item L.1, at 5:22:05–5:22:41.  ↩
  31. City Council meeting video, August 11, 2026, Item L.1, at 6:17:39.  ↩
  32. Brendan Ponton, “Apartments proposed for Back Bay Farmhouse Brewing land in Virginia Beach,” WTKR, March 2026.  ↩
  33. City Council meeting video, August 11, 2026, Item L.1, at 6:11:27.  ↩
  34. City Council meeting video, August 11, 2026, Item L.1, at 6:12:50.  ↩
  35. City Council meeting video, August 11, 2026, Item L.1, at 6:20:22.  ↩
  36. City Council meeting video, September 15, 2026, Item K.2, at 2:32:30–2:32:52 (Beaman).  ↩
  37. City Council meeting video, August 11, 2026, Item L.1, at 6:14:07.  ↩
  38. City Council meeting video, September 15, 2026, Item K.2, at 3:07:23.  ↩
  39. City Council meeting video, September 15, 2026, Item K.2, at 3:11:16.  ↩
  40. City Council meeting video, August 11, 2026, Item L.1, at 6:06:10.  ↩
  41. Planning Commission minutes, July 8, 2026, Items 6 and 7, PDF page 32.  ↩
  42. “Petition to reject building of multi family development at 1805 Kempsville Road,” change.org, started by Melody Batten, March 22, 2026 (6,657 signatures when viewed November 19, 2026).  ↩
  43. City Council meeting video, September 15, 2026, Item K.2, at 2:34:30.  ↩
  44. City Council meeting video, August 11, 2026, Item L.1, at 5:32:42–5:33:13.  ↩
  45. City Council meeting video, September 15, 2026, Item K.2, at 2:49:06.  ↩
  46. City Council meeting video, August 11, 2026, Item L.1, at 5:43:48.  ↩
  47. City Council summary of actions, August 11, 2026, Item L.1 (deferred for 30 days, 10-1); a speaker told Council on September 15 that Schulman “did not even agree to defer it” (meeting video at 3:03:20).  ↩
  48. Virginia Department of Elections, Dyer Difference, reports 145650, 220242, 277145, 403057, and 446366.  ↩
  49. Virginia Department of Elections, Rosemary Wilson for City Council, Friends for Rosemary Wilson, and Elect Rosemary, reports 184462, 221680, and 415720.  ↩
  50. Virginia Department of Elections, Friends of Michael Berlucchi and Friends of Michael F. Berlucchi, reports 180537, 221754, and 416056.  ↩
  51. Virginia Department of Elections, Cal for Council, report 448417.  ↩
  52. Virginia Department of Elections, Worth Remick for City Council, report 496879.  ↩
  53. Virginia Department of Elections, Schulman for City Council, report 496738.  ↩
  54. Virginia Department of Elections, Amelia for Virginia Beach, report 511977.  ↩
  55. Virginia Public Access Project, Bonaventure donor page, viewed November 17, 2026.  ↩
  56. City Council minutes, November 9, 1981, Item 17391, PDF page 40; March 26, 1984, Item 21616, PDF page 61; Virginia Beach land records, Amended Certificate of Partnership of B W Square, recorded April 8, 1988, instrument 198801036698.  ↩

Last updated November 19, 2026.

Have records or evidence about this?  Email keepvbabovewater@gmail.com.

Comments

Leave a Reply