Citizens v. Developers

Citizens v. Developers: When the public says no, and Council says yes.

Voters approve.  Residents sign petitions.  Civic leagues line up at the microphone.  Then the developers ask Council to look the other way . . . and Council does.

This is a running scorecard of every time Council sided with developers over what the public voted for or asked for, with the date, the vote, and the money.

The scorecard:

DateWhat the public wantedWho pushed backVote
2021 to 2026The flood bond’s “no net increase” stormwater promiseThe builders’ trade group, Virginia Beach Vision, and developersShelved 6-5; dropped from the new Comprehensive Plan 8-3
September 15, 2026No apartments at the Back Bay Farmhouse (6,556 signatures)BonaventureApproved 9-1
July 14, 2026No 52 condominiums at 3853 Shore DriveLisa Murphy, Brad MartinApproved 10-1
April 16, 2024Save the Great Neck lake lotsBishard, Eddie BourdonApproved 7-4
June 7, 2022No Amazon warehouse on Twin Mills Road (414 signatures)BT Holdings/Panattoni, Eddie BourdonApproved 11-0
September 22, 2020No 22-story tower on Shore DriveWestminster-CanterburyApproved 5-2
October 23, 1990Chesapeake Bay protection citywide, including Back BayTidewater Builders Association (Tuck Bowie)Bay watershed only, 11-0
1986 and 1987The power to protect trees from clear-cuttingVirginia Home Builders AssociationStruck in Richmond

Council members siding with developers:

  • Every time:  Bobby Dyer, Rosemary Wilson, and Michael Berlucchi (9 of 9 votes); David Hutcheson, Worth Remick, Amelia Ross-Hammond, and Joash Schulman (5 of 5); Stacy Cummings (3 of 3).1
  • The builders’ trade group pays them:  the Coastal Virginia Building Industry Association (CVBIA), formerly the Tidewater Builders Association, has given Wilson $8,750, Dyer $8,000, Berlucchi $3,000, Cummings $2,500, Schulman $2,500, Remick $1,500, Hutcheson $1,000, and Cash Jackson-Green $1,000.2

The same man, 1988 to today:  Tuck Bowie

  • April 18, 1988:  Richard “Tuck” Bowie, chairman of the Tidewater Builders Association’s Municipal Affairs Committee, asks Council for smaller lots and a seat for the builders in writing the City’s stormwater rules.3
  • October 23, 1990:  Bowie asks Council to keep the new Chesapeake Bay rules off Back Bay and the North Landing River.  Council agrees, 11-0.4
  • February 1, 2022:  Bowie asks Council to put off the flood bond promise:  “If there is concern with the optics of what your citizens voted on . . . which I doubt.”5
  • May 3, 2022:  Bowie speaks against the promise, and Council shelves it, 6-5.6
  • October 4, 2022:  on Wilson’s nomination, Council appoints Bowie to the Open Space Advisory Committee, 11-0.7
  • February 18, 2025:  Council seats Bowie on the stormwater advisory group for the “real estate development community.”  He is also vice chairman of Council’s Process Improvement Steering Committee.8

The flood bond promise:  Voters said yes, Council said later

To win the 2021 flood bond, Council promised that the City would recommend denying any development that adds stormwater.9  Voters approved the $567.5 million bond on November 2, 2021, with 72% voting yes.10  Council already knew it could say no to building over flooding.  On April 17, 2018, it denied Argos Properties II’s 50 acres on Princess Anne Road, 11-0, over flooding; Argos sued and lost.11  Argos’s attorney, Ann Crenshaw, became Virginia Beach Vision’s president.12  Argos’s agent, Brad Martin, became its chairman.  Then the builders went to work.

  • January 14, 2022:  Virginia Beach Vision writes Dyer and Council asking them to wait until the stormwater rules are redone with the development community, warning the rules “may impede” redevelopment.13
  • February 1, 2022:  Bowie, CVBIA chief executive Claudia Cotton (“dangerous precedent”), and developer Mark Ricketts ask for delay.  A motion to keep the promise fails, 5-5, with Dyer, Wilson, Berlucchi, Linwood Branch, and Sabrina Wooten voting ‘nay.’5
  • February 15, 2022:  with McClees of Virginia Beach Vision in support, Council sends the promise back to the Planning Commission, 8-3.  The only ‘nays’ are Barbara Henley, Louis Jones, and John Moss.14  Dyer:  “Rest assured, we did not violate our word.”
  • May 3, 2022:  Bowie, Cotton, Brad Martin, and Chris Wood speak against it.  Council shelves it indefinitely and hands it to the steering committee, 6-5:  Berlucchi, Branch, Dyer, Rocky Holcomb, Wilson, and Wooten vote ‘aye.’6
  • June 18, 2024:  Council creates the stormwater advisory group the steering committee asked for, 9-2, and later seats Bowie and Ricketts on it.  The CVBIA had given Dyer $4,000 on May 28, 2024, one week before he co-sponsored it.15  The only ‘nays’ are Chris Taylor and Wooten.
  • April 21, 2026:  Council adopts the new Comprehensive Plan without the promise, 8-3, with Lisa Murphy speaking in support.  The ‘nays’ are Henley, Jackson-Green, and Jennifer Rouse.16

The Farmhouse:  6,556 signatures

On September 15, 2026, Council approves Bonaventure’s 251 apartments at the Back Bay Farmhouse, 9-1, over a petition with 6,556 signatures and the Brigadoon and Charlestowne civic leagues.17  The only ‘nay’ is Henley.  In the 12 days before the vote, the CVBIA gave Remick $1,500, Cummings $1,500, and Schulman $1,500, Schulman’s on the day of the vote.18  Full story in The Back Bay Farmhouse.

Shore Drive:  13 speakers against

On July 14, 2026, Council approves 52 condominiums at 3853 Shore Drive, 10-1, over 13 speakers, including the Ocean Park Civic League’s president.19  Murphy is the attorney, and Virginia Beach Vision chairman Brad Martin speaks in support.  Schulman makes the motion.  At the Planning Commission, a resident had pointed out that the flood promise “was omitted from the recently adopted comprehensive plan.”20  The only ‘nay’ is Henley.

The Great Neck lake:  Three civic groups against

On April 16, 2024, Council approves Bishard’s lots on the Wycliffe Presbyterian Church land, 7-4, on Ross-Hammond’s motion and Wilson’s second.  Ten people speak against, including the Great Neck Estates Civic League, The Lake Association, and the Chesapeake Beach East Condo Association; Eddie Bourdon is the attorney.21  The ‘nays’ are Henley, Jennifer Rouse, Taylor, and Wooten.

The Amazon warehouse:  414 signatures

On June 7, 2022, Council approves the Twin Mills Road warehouse site, 11-0, over 414 signatures and five residents at the microphone.22  The full story is in Amaz[off].

The Shore Drive tower:  Two dozen speakers against

On September 22, 2020, Council approves Westminster-Canterbury’s 22-story tower at 3100 Shore Drive, 5-2, with three members abstaining, over more than two dozen speakers and the Shore Drive Community Coalition.23  The VBDA later approves up to $525 million in bonds for the project.24

Before 2018:

Chesapeake Bay rules, 1990:  The Virginia Beach Garden Club, the League of Women Voters, SAVE, and the Back Bay Restoration Foundation ask Council to protect every watershed in the City.  Bowie, for the Tidewater Builders Association, asks for the Bay watershed only.  State law already required every Tidewater city to protect “the Chesapeake Bay, its tributaries, and other state waters” in its plans and zoning.25  On October 23, 1990, Council gives the builders their version anyway, 11-0, and promises Back Bay and the North Landing River rules “within six months.”4  They come 17 months later, on March 24, 1992.26

Trees, 1986 and 1987:  With residents “increasingly aware of and concerned over the loss of trees,” the City asks the General Assembly for the power to stop needless tree removal.27  In 1986, the tree clause “received much opposition most especially from the Virginia Home Builders Association” and is “stricken from the BILL.”28  The 1987 request fails too, and the City asks again for 1988 “pursuant to the stated wishes of the citizens and the Council.”29

Notes and sources:

  1. Count of the nine 2021 to 2026 Council votes listed in this post on the flood bond promise, the Farmhouse, Shore Drive, Wycliffe, and the Amazon site, for members serving today.  A vote “with the developers” is a vote to delay, refer, or drop the flood bond promise, to create the stormwater advisory group, or to approve the project over the opposition.  KVBAW Public Will Log, Votes tab.  ↩
  2. Virginia Public Access Project, Coastal Va Building Industry Assn, contributions to Virginia Beach City Council and mayoral committees, 2007 to 2026, retrieved November 16, 2026.  The CVBIA gives its address as 2117 Smith Avenue, Chesapeake, the same address the Tidewater Builders Association gave Council in 1988 (City Council minutes, March 2, 1988, PDF page 2; February 1, 2022, Item 72477, PDF pages 175–177).  ↩
  3. City Council minutes, April 18, 1988, Item 29219, PDF page 24.  ↩
  4. City Council minutes, October 23, 1990, Item 33628, PDF pages 50–53.  ↩
  5. City Council minutes, February 1, 2022, Item 72477, PDF pages 175–177; Brett Hall, WAVY, February 1, 2022.  ↩
  6. City Council minutes, May 3, 2022, Item 72818, PDF pages 159–160.  ↩
  7. City Council minutes, October 4, 2022, Item 73375, PDF page 78.  ↩
  8. Stormwater Management Implementation Advisory Group, membership roster, 2025; City Council minutes, June 18, 2024, Item 75843, PDF page 75.  ↩
  9. City Council minutes, September 7, 2021, Item 71975 (resolution, commitment 3), 10-0.  ↩
  10. Regina Mobley, WAVY, November 3, 2021; Virginia Beach Vision and Greater Norfolk Corporation, letter to the Virginia Beach and Norfolk General Assembly delegations, February 9, 2022 (“passing with 72% of the vote”).  ↩
  11. City Council minutes, April 17, 2018, Item 68008, PDF page 172 (Ann Crenshaw, attorney, and Brad Martin, agent, for the applicant; ten residents opposed); Argos Properties II, LLC v. City Council of Virginia Beach, Virginia Beach Circuit Court, petition dismissed April 24, 2019.  ↩
  12. Virginia Beach Vision, letter to Mayor Dyer and City Council on the Resort Area Strategic Action Plan, March 10, 2020, signed by Ann Crenshaw, President/Chairman of the Board.  ↩
  13. Virginia Beach Vision, letter to Mayor Dyer and City Council, January 14, 2022, signed by Delceno C. Miles, president, and Martha S. McClees, executive director.  ↩
  14. City Council minutes, February 15, 2022, Item 72527, PDF page 87; Brett Hall, WAVY, February 18, 2022.  ↩
  15. City Council minutes, June 4, 2024, Item 75749, PDF pages 20–26 (requested by Mayor Dyer and Council Member Schulman); June 18, 2024, Item 75843, PDF page 75; VPAP, CVBIA to Dyer for Virginia Beach Mayor.  ↩
  16. City Council minutes, April 21, 2026, Item 78250, PDF pages 199–200.  ↩
  17. City Council minutes, September 15, 2026, Item K.2, PDF pages 104–105; Planning Commission minutes, July 8, 2026.  ↩
  18. VPAP, CVBIA to Remick (September 3, 2026), Cummings (September 10, 2026), and Schulman (September 15, 2026).  ↩
  19. City Council minutes, July 14, 2026, Item 78577, PDF pages 102–104.  ↩
  20. Planning Commission, June 10, 2026, Shore Drive Area Properties, LLC (verbatim transcript).  ↩
  21. City Council minutes, April 16, 2024, Item 75557, PDF pages 184–187.  ↩
  22. City Council minutes, June 7, 2022, Item 72955, PDF page 125; Planning Commission minutes, May 11, 2022.  ↩
  23. City Council minutes, September 22, 2020; 13News Now and WAVY coverage, September 2020.  ↩
  24. City Council minutes, November 14, 2023, Item 74955, PDF page 203.  ↩
  25. Va. Code § 62.1-44.15:67(A)(i) and § 62.1-44.15:74(B)–(D) (Chesapeake Bay Preservation Act, 1988, formerly §§ 10.1-2100 and 10.1-2109); § 62.1-44.15:68 (Virginia Beach is in “Tidewater Virginia”).  ↩
  26. City Council actions, March 24, 1992 (Appendix G, Southern Watersheds Management Ordinance, adopted); City Council minutes, March 10, 1992 (rescheduled to March 24, 1992).  ↩
  27. City Council minutes, November 24, 1986, 1987 legislative package (Tree Protection Ordinance), PDF page 48.  ↩
  28. City Council minutes, March 10, 1986, Item 25079, PDF page 79.  ↩
  29. City Council minutes, March 9, 1987, Item 26933, PDF page 8; November 16, 1987, Item 28344, PDF page 11.  ↩

Last updated November 19, 2026.

Have records or evidence about this?  Email keepvbabovewater@gmail.com.

Comments

Leave a Reply