The Cavalier, a/k/a Cavalier Associates, LLC, is the Bruce Thompson and Gold Key | PHR developer group that rebuilt the 1927 Cavalier Hotel with $13,019,040 of City money and up to $24.5 million in state and City sales taxes, then sold it on June 15, 2026, for about $174 million.1, 2, 3, 4
The Cavalier’s biggest conflict: a TowneBank director and the VBDA chairman whose firm counts Gold Key as a client voting to hand the Cavalier’s tax deal to its buyer, and a Council member whose firm lists a Cavalier Associates building seconding it.5, 6

The sale: A TowneBank director and a Cavalier broker’s employee vote ‘aye’
- May 12, 2026: The VBDA votes ‘aye’, 10-0, with no discussion, to let Cavalier Associates hand its gap financing agreement to the buyer, Wheelock Street Capital. Eric Keplinger moves and Michael Harris seconds. Chairman Lisa Murphy, Akhil Jain, and Don Horsley vote ‘aye’. Council’s VBDA liaisons, Rosemary Wilson and Michael Berlucchi, are in the room.5
- Akhil Jain sits on TowneBank’s Virginia Beach board. TowneBank was Cavalier Associates’ lender, with a $77,094,836 credit line recorded February 23, 2016.7
- Lisa Murphy is a partner at Willcox & Savage, which has counted Gold Key | PHR as a client.8
- May 19, 2026: Council votes ‘aye’, 9-0, by consent, to approve the handoff. Barbara Henley moves and Worth Remick seconds. Berlucchi, Stacy Cummings, Mayor Bobby Dyer, David Hutcheson, Cal Jackson-Green, Jennifer Rouse, and Joash Schulman also vote ‘aye’.6
- Worth Remick works for Colliers International Virginia, LLC. In a letter filed that day, Remick wrote that Colliers “is the listing agent for an office building that is owned by Cavalier Associates, LLC.” Remick then seconded the motion.6
- Barbara Henley, who made the motion, has received $5,500 from the Cavalier team.
The law: Va. Code § 2.2-3112(A) requires an official with a personal interest in a transaction to disqualify himself, and § 2.2-3115(F) requires the interest to be disclosed in the agency’s records. No disclosure by Jain or Murphy appears in the May 12, 2026 VBDA minutes.5 For Remick, § 2.2-3112(B)(2) lets an official vote on a firm client he does not serve himself, after the declaration in § 2.2-3115(I).
Standing conflicts:
Still standing today
Nine sitting Council members have received $92,750 from the Cavalier team.9
- Michael Berlucchi: $23,250. Berlucchi seconded the Cavalier’s beach franchise on April 1, 2025, and voted ‘aye’ on the handoff 55 days after $3,500 from PHR/GKR Holding Co.10, 6
- Mayor Bobby Dyer: $20,000. As a Council member, Dyer voted ‘nay’ on the Cavalier money in 2013, 2014, and 2017.2, 11, 3 As Mayor, with $20,000 from the Cavalier team, Dyer voted ‘aye’ on the beach franchise and the handoff.10, 6
- Vice Mayor Rosemary Wilson: $15,500. Wilson seconded the 2013 package and the 2014 gap financing, voted ‘aye’ on the 2017 increase, and made the motion for the 2025 beach franchise.2, 11, 3, 10
- Amelia Ross-Hammond: $13,500. Ross-Hammond received $3,500 from Steve Lawson and PHR/GKR Holding Co. 32 to 35 days before her ‘aye’ on the beach franchise.10
- Cal Jackson-Green: $9,000. All from Thompson, in 2024. Jackson-Green voted ‘aye’ on the beach franchise and the handoff.10, 6
- Barbara Henley: $5,500. Henley voted ‘aye’ in 2013, 2014, and 2017, and made the motion for the handoff.2, 11, 3, 6
- Joash Schulman: $2,500. Schulman spoke on the Cavalier’s side of the Atlantic Avenue fight on December 11, 2018, received $2,500 from PHR/GKR Holding Co. on November 5, 2022, and voted ‘aye’ on the handoff.12, 6
- Stacy Cummings: $2,500. Cummings voted ‘aye’ on the beach franchise and the handoff.10, 6
- Worth Remick: $1,000. From Steve Lawson on June 12, 2025. Remick’s firm lists a Cavalier Associates building, and Remick seconded the handoff.6
- A TowneBank director on the VBDA: Council appointed Akhil Jain on March 4, 2025, 9-0, on Wilson’s nomination, for a term through August 31, 2027.13
- Thompson’s City tourism seat with no end date: On August 18, 2020, Vice Mayor Jim Wood nominated Thompson to the Convention & Visitors Bureau Community Task Force with “No Term.” The only ‘nay’ for Thompson came from John Moss.14
- The tax deal runs on: State and City sales taxes from the resort still pay down the Cavalier’s gap financing, now for the buyer. The City says the handoff “would not increase the financial commitment of the Commonwealth, the City or the Authority.”6
Days apart: The gifts and the votes

The lawn: $2.37 million, then built on without asking
The City paid Cavalier Associates $2,370,000 on July 19, 2013, for a green space easement over the hotel’s front lawn.1A In February 2021, a resident reported work going on in the lawn. The City Manager later confirmed Cavalier Associates had to get City approval “prior to the commencement of any permanent changes. They did not.” It also skipped the normal permits. “The City Manager has communicated telephonically with Bruce L. Thompson.”1
Then the City Manager approved the work after the fact, writing that a majority of Council concurred. When John Moss asked that majority to identify themselves, Mayor Dyer warned against “micro-managing,” Berlucchi questioned whether Council should be discussing the permit violations at all, and Henley said Cavalier Associates had apologized and she was satisfied. Moss called the issue “closed.”1 The City Manager told Council that Thompson called it an oversight, and that Cavalier Associates did not want to pay a fine. Kerry Dougherty reported that he approved it after six Council members told him privately they were in favor.15
It was not the first time. In 2018, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers found the Cavalier Beach Club had planted palm trees and built a wood deck and fencing on the federal seawall without asking. Gold Key asked for permission after the fact, which the Corps called “rare,” and the City’s water resources engineer took Thompson’s side against the Corps. The Corps warned that if the trees stayed, Virginia Beach could lose its eligibility for federal help after a flood or storm. City Manager Dave Hansen still wrote the Corps on July 26, 2018 supporting Thompson’s request to keep them. Thompson, in a text, called the issue “no big deal” and “stupid.”16, 17 In September 2019 the Corps ordered the palms removed. Thompson called it “extremely disappointing.”18
Recent votes: The beach franchise and the handoff
- April 1, 2025: Council votes ‘aye’, 11-0, by consent, to give Cavalier Associates a franchise for beach operations on the sand east of 4101 and 4201 Atlantic Avenue. Wilson moves and Berlucchi seconds.10
- May 2026: The handoff, above. Wilson and Ross-Hammond are absent from the Council vote.6
Atlantic Avenue: Rebuilding a public street for the Cavalier
- June 5, 2018: Council votes ‘aye’, 6-3, to keep seeking state grants for the Atlantic Avenue reconfiguration at the Cavalier. Ben Davenport moves and Wilson seconds. Davenport, Henley, Jones, Kane, Wilson, and Wood vote ‘aye’.19 Nutter gives Wood $1,000 on May 21, 2018, 15 days before, and The Lawson Company gives Wood $500 on June 14, 2018, nine days after.
- September 2018: Before the Council election, Thompson texts The Virginian-Pilot: “Clearly if the election brings out a change in leadership, me and most other developers will not be interested in investment in the city.”20
- December 2018: City Manager Dave Hansen tells Council the owner of Pacifica restaurant at 40th Street, whose land the project needs, is a “willing seller.” The owner, Chris Glover, tells Kerry Dougherty he is not, and that City real estate staff told him “if I didn’t, it’s going to happen in five years.” Thompson agrees to pay the $2.5 million cost only after the City fails to get the state to pay.21
- December 11, 2018: A motion to stop the reconfiguration fails, 3-7. Nutter and Josh Schulman, now Councilman Joash Schulman, speak against stopping it. Davenport, Henley, Jones, Kane, Wilson, Wood, and Sabrina Wooten vote ‘nay’, keeping the project alive.12 Thompson had given Wooten $2,500 on November 1, 2018, 40 days before. Moss, after the vote: “We are setting a precedent that if your checkbook’s big enough, and the profit to the city’s balance sheet is large enough, then the fundamental principles of our republic don’t matter — because it’s all about the money.”22
The money: The Cavalier team’s gifts to Council
- Michael Berlucchi: Thompson $2,500 and Nutter $1,000 on August 9, 2019; Steve Lawson $500 on October 21, 2019; Nutter $1,000 on March 5, 2020; PHR/GKR $5,000 and Frye $500 on September 19, 2020; Frye $1,000 on February 22, 2022; Nutter $750 on March 10, 2022; Lawson $500 on March 16, 2022, and February 10, 2023; Nutter $500 on May 4, 2024; Thompson $5,000 on August 21, 2024; Lawson $500 on September 3, 2024, and January 5, 2025; PHR/GKR $3,500 on March 25, 2026. Total $23,250.
- Mayor Bobby Dyer: The Lawson Companies $500 on October 5, 2018, and October 7, 2020; Frye $1,000 on January 15, 2020; Nutter $500 on August 31, 2020, and December 29, 2023; Reidy $500 on October 22, 2020; Thompson $5,000 on October 26, 2020; Steve Lawson $1,000 on June 5, 2024; Thompson $10,000 on October 17, 2024; Lawson $500 on October 22, 2024. Total $20,000.
- Vice Mayor Rosemary Wilson: Nutter $1,000 and Steve Lawson $1,000 on May 28, 2019; Levinson $500 on September 30, 2019; Lawson $500 on October 4, 2019; Thompson $1,000 on November 6, 2019; Frye $1,000 on August 4, 2020; Thompson $500 on August 31, 2020; Nutter $1,000 on September 21, 2020; Lawson $500 on October 7, 2020; Thompson $2,500 on June 23, 2022; Lawson $1,000 on March 29, 2024; Thompson $5,000 on September 27, 2024. Total $15,500.
- Amelia Ross-Hammond: Steve Lawson $500 on August 29, 2022; Lawson $1,000 on February 25, 2025, and PHR/GKR $2,500 on February 28, 2025; Thompson $1,000 and Lawson $1,000 on June 30, 2026, 15 days after the sale closed. Total $13,500, including $7,500 before 2018.
- Cal Jackson-Green: Thompson $5,000 on August 7, 2024, and $4,000 on October 30, 2024. Total $9,000.
- Barbara Henley: Nutter $1,000 on October 4, 2018; Frye $2,500 on October 13, 2022; Nutter $500 on October 22, 2022. Total $5,500, including $1,500 before 2018.
- Joash Schulman: PHR/GKR $2,500 on November 5, 2022.
- Stacy Cummings: Thompson $1,500 on April 8, 2024; Levinson $1,000 on August 1, 2024. Total $2,500.
- Worth Remick: Steve Lawson $1,000 on June 12, 2025.
Jim Wood: Nutter $1,000 on May 21, 2018; The Lawson Company $500 on June 14, 2018; Frye $1,000 on July 8, 2018; Thompson $5,000 on August 14, 2018. Total $8,500, including $1,000 before 2018.Sabrina Wooten: Thompson $5,000 on September 12, 2018, $2,500 on November 1, 2018, and $2,000 on March 25, 2019. Total $9,500.Ben Davenport: Steve Lawson $500 on October 4, 2018. Total $5,500, including $5,000 before 2018.
The buyer: Wheelock Street Capital
Wheelock Street Capital, of Connecticut, bought the Historic Cavalier, the Beach Club, the Oceanfront Marriott, and the Embassy Suites with HEI Hotels & Resorts, which manages them. The Hunt Room and Tarnished Truth Distilling were not part of the sale.4, 23
Before 2018: How the deal was made
- 2010: Thompson chairs the tourism subcommittee of Governor Bob McDonnell’s Commission on Economic Development and Job Creation. The subcommittee recommends a financing program “to help developers close deals on large tourism projects.” Under it, the state and the City hand a project’s own sales taxes back to pay down the developer’s debt. The Cavalier later uses it.24
- Spring 2013: City records show the deal steered to Thompson before the auction. On March 29, 2013, City Manager Jim Spore tells a rival bidder that zoning does not allow single-family homes on the Cavalier land. About a week later, City staff send Thompson’s Cavalier, LLC a detailed package promising $19 million in public aid and permission for 86 single-family homes. On April 23, 2013, Finance Director Patti Phillips suggests using tourism tax money, “assuming BT is agreeable.” The City presents the whole incentive package to Thompson’s team at least two months before the first public meeting on June 11, 2013. Staff then design a no-bid contract for Thompson to build Cavalier Drive, based on an estimate a City engineer wrote on June 26, 2013 was too inflated to use.25
- June 2013: A week before the public hearing, Thompson shows a reporter a hotel bar and jokes, “This is where we work out our deals, in dark back rooms. Everything you’ve heard is true.”26
- July 2, 2013: Council votes ‘aye’, 7-1, for the Cavalier package: $8,200,000 in economic development (EDIP) money; $2,370,000 from the Open Space Program for a “green space” easement over the hotel lawn; $2,449,040 moved out of two City land-acquisition accounts to build Cavalier Drive; and a franchise for beach operations. John Uhrin moves and Rosemary Wilson seconds. Glenn Davis, Barbara Henley, Louis Jones, Amelia Ross-Hammond, Uhrin, Wilson, and Jim Wood vote ‘aye’. The only ‘nay’ is Bobby Dyer.2 Gold Key | PHR had given Ross-Hammond $1,500 on May 28, 2013, 35 days before. At the public hearing, a resident said he was not opposed to preserving the hotel but to “using taxpayers’ money to do so.”27
- December 10, 2013: Council rezones the Cavalier on the Hill land from RT-1 Resort Tourist and R-7.5 Residential to Oceanfront Resort for “The Village at The Cavalier on the Hill.” Nutter, the developer’s attorney, calls it “a win/win for everyone involved.” Wilson moves and Davis seconds; it passes 9-0.28
- February 11, 2014: Council endorses state gap financing for the Cavalier, $4 million for the Historic Cavalier and $14 million for the Oceanfront Cavalier, 8-2. Henley, Jones, Shannon Kane, Brad Martin, Ross-Hammond, Uhrin, Wilson, and Wood vote ‘aye’; Dyer and John Moss vote ‘nay’. Twenty-seven days later, on March 10, 2014, Thompson gives Kane $5,000.11B
- John Uhrin: After Uhrin voted for the Cavalier’s $18 million, the developer hired his wife to market luxury homes on the Cavalier property, one week after the vote.29
- March 7, 2017: Council raises the gap financing by $6.5 million, to $24.5 million, for an Embassy Suites. Speakers against it tell Council that “these types of projects are always asking for more money that ultimately are funded by the Citizens,” and that more than 1,208 residents signed a petition against the Atlantic Avenue realignment that came with it.30 Ben Davenport moves and Jim Wood seconds. Nutter tells Council that “Bruce Thompson has developed numerous successful projects throughout the City with no City funding,” and that the only one with public money was 31st Street.31 That is false: four years earlier Council had given the Cavalier, Nutter’s own client, $8.2 million in economic development money and $2.37 million for the lawn easement, and in 2002 the VBDA had bought Thompson’s Beach Quarters Inn for $2.5 million and leased it back to him.2 Dyer’s motion to put the increase off indefinitely fails, 3-5. It passes 5-3, with Davenport, Henley, Jones, Wilson, and Wood voting ‘aye’ and Jessica Abbott, Dyer, and Moss voting ‘nay’. Five weeks earlier, on February 1, 2017, the Wood family had signed a $5.6 million credit line with TowneBank, the Cavalier’s lender. Wood’s vote decided it.3 See our Wood post.
- Bryan Cuffee: Gold Key | PHR’s vice president joined the VBDA in September 2011. Cuffee held a stake in the Cavalier through a separate LLC since at least January 1, 2017. On February 21, 2017, the day the VBDA took up the Cavalier, Gold Key’s Robert M. Howard told the VBDA in writing that no City official had an interest in the project.7
- Michael Levinson: A partner in COTH, LLC, an original 2013 Cavalier investor, Levinson sat on the VBDA from 2014 to 2018 and sits on TowneBank’s Virginia Beach board.7
- Linwood Branch: Thompson’s Ocean Beach Club, LLC signed a three-year, $10,000-a-year contract with Branch’s family motel, the Lynn-Dee, in 2013. Branch voted for the second Cavalier grant on the VBDA in 2017.32
- The bond warning: An April 2018 document for a $25 million Virginia Small Business Financing Authority bond for the Cavalier warned investors they would be at significant risk if Council or the VBDA stopped the tourism grant.7 TowneBank, where Levinson and Cuffee were directors, recorded a $77,094,836 loan on the Cavalier Residences land on February 23, 2016.33
- Dot Wood: Jim Wood’s mother chaired the VBDA when it took up the Cavalier on February 21, 2017, three weeks after the family’s TowneBank credit line. See our Wood post.
- Gifts before 2018: Ross-Hammond: Gold Key | PHR $1,500 on May 28, 2013; Nutter $1,000 on August 23, 2016; PHR/GKR $5,000 on October 26, 2016. Henley: PHR/GKR $1,000 on September 12, 2014; Frye $500 on October 30, 2014.
Wood: Nutter $1,000 on April 12, 2014.Davenport: PHR/GKR $5,000 on June 9, 2014.Kane: Thompson $5,000 on March 10, 2014.
Taken from the public:
- $10,570,000 to Bruce Thompson (Cavalier Associates, LLC): $8,200,000 in economic development (EDIP) money and $2,370,000 for the lawn easement, July 2, 2013. Running total: $10,570,000. ↩
- Up to $24,500,000 to Bruce Thompson (Cavalier Associates, LLC): state and City sales taxes returned through gap financing, $18 million endorsed February 11, 2014, raised to $24.5 million March 7, 2017; handed to the buyer May 19, 2026. Running total: $10,570,000, plus up to $24,500,000. ↩
Total in this post: $10,570,000, plus up to $24,500,000 more promised. Total owed to the public, all posts: $43,851,464.37, plus up to $20.9 million more promised.
Notes and sources:
- City Council minutes, April 6, 2021, Item 71484, PDF pages 151–155 (City Manager’s answers to Council Member Moss). ↩
- City Council minutes, July 2, 2013, Item 62964, PDF page 44. ↩
- City Council minutes, March 7, 2017, Item 66845, PDF pages 141–143. ↩
- WTKR, “Filings show Historic Cavalier Hotel, Oceanfront properties sold for over $174M”. ↩
- VBDA minutes, May 12, 2026, Item 4, PDF pages 1 and 4–5. ↩
- City Council minutes, May 19, 2026, Item K.2 (Item 78358), PDF pages 50–53. ↩
- Kerry Dougherty, “Special Feature: Connections and Conflicts,” October 11, 2018, and the deed of trust in her Conflicts documents. ↩
- VBDA Index of Abstain Letters, entry for November 17, 2020 (Lisa Murphy, CARES Act awards: Willcox & Savage “provides legal services to 9 applicants, including Gold Key/PHR”). ↩
- The Cavalier team: Bruce Thompson and his companies (Gold Key | PHR, PHR/GKR Holding Co.); partners John and Steve Lawson (The Lawson Companies), Bart Frye (Frye Properties), and Frank Reidy; original investor Michael Levinson; and the developer’s attorney, R. J. Nutter. Gifts under $500 are left off. Virginia Department of Elections campaign finance reports, Schedule A, for each committee listed. ↩
- City Council minutes, April 1, 2025, Item 76858, PDF page 170. ↩
- City Council minutes, February 11, 2014, Item 63470, PDF page 62. ↩
- City Council minutes, December 11, 2018, Item 68748, PDF page 139. ↩
- City Council minutes, March 4, 2025, Item 76746, PDF page 117. ↩
- City Council minutes, August 18, 2020, Item 70661, PDF page 140. ↩
- Kerry Dougherty, “Cronyism Is Back In Virginia Beach,” April 8, 2021. ↩
- Alissa Skelton, “Cavalier Hotel developer and federal government are in dispute over palm trees,” The Virginian-Pilot, August 1, 2018 (printed copy on the Keep Virginia Beach Above Water Facebook page). ↩
- “Army Corps: Cavalier Beach Club also built unauthorized fencing and wood deck,” Southside Daily/WYDaily, August 15, 2018; Kerry Dougherty, “The Politics Of Palm Trees,” August 6, 2018. ↩
- “Army Corps orders palm trees removed from Cavalier Beach Club in Virginia Beach,” WAVY, October 2, 2019. ↩
- City Council minutes, June 5, 2018, Item 68174, PDF page 46. ↩
- Kerry Dougherty, “What If The Good-Government Guys Win?” September 10, 2018, quoting The Virginian-Pilot. ↩
- Kerry Dougherty, “Showdown In Cronytown,” December 10, 2018. ↩
- “City councilman: Atlantic Avenue redesign deal is ‘all about the money,’” Southside Daily/WYDaily, December 13, 2018. ↩
- WHRO, June 18, 2026. ↩
- Virginian-Pilot, “Cavalier developers in Virginia Beach want more public financing, this time for another hotel,” January 20, 2017, reprinted by Hotel Online. ↩
- John Holland, “Special Feature: Connections and Conflicts, Part II,” kerrydougherty.com, October 14, 2018 (from City records obtained under FOIA, the same records a federal grand jury subpoenaed). ↩
- “Va. Beach Cavalier developer unfazed by criticism,” Associated Press via 13NewsNow, June 24, 2013. ↩
- City Council minutes, July 2, 2013, Item 62962, PDF page 42. ↩
- City Council minutes, December 10, 2013, Item 63401, PDF pages 170–171. ↩
- James C. Sherlock, “Atlantic Park Part 4: Seven Years of Negotiations,” Bacon’s Rebellion, September 12, 2024; Kerry Dougherty, “The Audacity of John Uhrin,” November 20, 2018. ↩
- City Council minutes, March 7, 2017, Item 66841, PDF page 122. ↩
- City Council minutes, March 7, 2017, Item 66845, PDF page 141 (the minutes’ summary of R. J. Nutter’s remarks). ↩
- John Holland, “Special Feature: Good Government. Virginia Beach-Style. Part II,” kerrydougherty.com, September 6, 2018. ↩
- Deed of trust, Oceanfront Investments, LLC to TBVAT, LLC (TowneBank), Instrument No. 201600014813, recorded February 23, 2016. ↩
Last updated November 21, 2026.
Have records or evidence about this? Email keepvbabovewater@gmail.com.

Leave a Reply