Owed to the Public

Owed to the Public ledger: $38,969,964.37 owed to the residents of Virginia Beach

This ledger adds up the public money and public land that City Council and the VBDA handed to private individuals, and what residents paid to fix builders’ problems.  The creditor is the residents of Virginia Beach.  Each account names the person who benefited, who voted for it, and who helped them get it.

Land counts at assessed value minus the price paid.  Each entry is counted once, even when several posts mention it.  “Promised” amounts are “up to” caps the City has agreed to; they stay out of the balance because the final amount is not set.

Total owed to the public:  $38,969,964.37, plus up to $18,800,000 more promised and $404,682 in estimated grants.  Residents also paid $11,122,796, plus up to $2,341,640 more, to fix builders’ drainage (Part II).

Summary of accounts

AccountOwedPromised (up to)
1.  Helen E. Dragas16,809,30013,800,000
2.  Mike Culpepper (Venture Realty Group)3,000,000
3.  Acoustical Sheetmetal’s owners1,749,999.60
4.  Steven W. Bishard1,022,369
5.  Greg Twitt (Globalinx)800,000
6.  Willcox & Savage clients and their landlords485,133.77
7.  Taylor Franklin (The Franklin Group)1,000,000404,682 (estimated)
8.  Ryan Turner (TST Tactical Defense Solutions)1,508,000
9.  Mike Standing (CLM Watermans Hotel and Waves 18, LLC)4,657,9005,000,000
10.  Bruce Thompson (Gold Key | PHR)7,937,262
Total owed to the public$38,969,964.37$19,204,682
Part II, kept separate:  residents paid, builders profited, $11,122,796, plus up to $2,341,640

Account 1:  Helen E. Dragas

Through Dragas Associates, Inc.  Details:  Dragas City Ties.

DateEntryDescriptionOwedPromised (up to)Balance
August 11, 20261-1341.4 acres at VB National, at assessed value.  The $17,940,000 price is paid back to Dragas for golf course work, so the City keeps nothing for the land.110,689,30010,689,300
August 11, 20261-2VBDA cash21,820,00012,509,300
August 11, 20261-3City payment for roads, sewer, and utilities24,300,00016,809,300
August 11, 20261-4Cost overruns23,600,00016,809,300
August 11, 20261-5“Performance grant,” adjusted for inflation, from the property’s new real estate taxes310,200,00016,809,300
Balance owed to the public13,800,000$16,809,300

Voted for it:  Mayor Bobby Dyer, Vice Mayor Rosemary Wilson (moved), Michael Berlucchi, Amelia Ross-Hammond, Stacy Cummings, Cal Jackson-Green, Joash Schulman, David Hutcheson (seconded), and Jennifer Rouse, August 11, 2026, 9-2.  Barbara Henley and Worth Remick voted ‘nay’.4

Helped her get it:  Deputy City Manager Amanda Jarratt and Economic Development’s Laura Hayes Chalk met Helen Dragas and her attorney, Eddie Bourdon, on April 22, 2024, and City staff sent her the course records.  Chuck Rigney handled her request for secrecy and exclusivity.  City Attorney Mark Stiles urged Councilmember Chris Taylor not to make the proposals public.  Dyer and Wilson met her privately in the mayor’s office on September 27, 2024.5

Account 2:  Mike Culpepper (Venture Realty Group)

Through Venture Waves, LLC, the Atlantic Park surf park developer.

DateEntryDescriptionOwedBalance
March 10, 20262-1Atlantic Park settlement:  $3,000,000 in City cash.  About 1.842 acres of VBDA land south of 18th Street went to Waves 18, LLC in the same settlement; that land is in Account 9.63,000,0003,000,000
Balance owed to the public$3,000,000

Voted for it:  VBDA commissioners Michael Harris (moved), Penny Morgan (seconded), Chairman Lisa Murphy, and Don Horsley, March 10, 2026, 4-0, with three commissioners abstaining.

Account 3:  Acoustical Sheetmetal’s owners

The Shaia family, RTK Family Capital’s Jeff Moore, and Young Capital’s Jim Young, through Acoustical Sheetmetal Company (“Project Encore”).  Details:  ASC is not for we.

DateEntryDescriptionOwedBalance
June 13, 20253-1EDIP Part A grant from the VBDA7828,130.60828,130.60
June 13, 20253-2City land discount on 21.97 acres in Innovation Park, sold at $147,019 an acre7921,8691,749,999.60
Balance owed to the public$1,749,999.60

Voted for it:  VBDA, June 13, 2025, 10-0.  Taylor Franklin moved the grant and Guenter Weissenseel seconded it; Akhil Jain moved the land sale and Mike Standing seconded it.

Account 4:  Steven W. Bishard

Through Bishard Homes, LLC.  City lots sold below the assessment shown on each deed.

DateEntryDescriptionOwedBalance
October 7, 20144-1Roselynn Lane, Middle Lane, and Indiana Avenue lots:  $165,000 for land assessed at $423,2008258,200258,200
May 17, 20164-2Michigan Avenue lots:  $72,500 for land assessed at $239,7009167,200425,400
May 17 and September 20, 20164-3Ego Drive lots:  $172,731 for land assessed at $695,700.  The City had paid $167,900 for two of these lots eight months earlier.10522,969948,369
December 11, 20184-4Three North Oceana Boulevard lots:  $195,000 for land assessed at $269,0001174,0001,022,369
Balance owed to the public$1,022,369

Voted for it:  October 7, 2014 (9-0):  Bobby Dyer, Barbara Henley, Mayor Louis Jones, Shannon Kane, Brad Martin, John Moss, Will Sessoms, John Uhrin, and Jim Wood.  May 17, 2016 (9-0):  Ben Davenport, Henley, Jones, Kane, Moss, Amelia Ross-Hammond, Uhrin, Rosemary Wilson, and Wood (seconded).  September 20, 2016 (10-0):  Davenport, Dyer, Henley, Jones, Kane, Moss, Ross-Hammond, Uhrin, Wilson, and Wood.  December 11, 2018 (10-0):  Davenport, Dyer, Henley, Jones, Kane, Moss, Uhrin, Wilson, Wood (moved), and Sabrina Wooten.

Account 5:  Greg Twitt (Globalinx)

Through Globalinx data center, LLC, at Corporate Landing.  Details:  Will Sessoms.

DateEntryDescriptionOwedBalance
May 12, 20265-1EDIP Part A grant from the VBDA for a $34.5 million expansion12800,000800,000
Balance owed to the public$800,000

Voted for it:  VBDA, May 12, 2026, 10-0.  Guenter Weissenseel moved and Eric Keplinger seconded.

Account 6:  Willcox & Savage clients and their landlords

Grants to businesses that, or whose landlords, use the law firm of VBDA Chairman Lisa Murphy.  Details:  Willcox & Savage.

DateEntryDescriptionOwedBalance
October 20, 20206-140 EDIP Part E grants to businesses that, or whose landlords, use Willcox & Savage13330,537.77330,537.77
March 21, 20236-214 Facade Improvement Grants the firm “may have” served14109,385439,922.77
March 11, 20256-39 Facade Improvement Grants, including JMT Sweets & More, LLC1545,211485,133.77
Balance owed to the public$485,133.77

Voted for it:  VBDA, October 20, 2020, 7-0, including Lisa Murphy and Dot Wood, whose son works for grantees’ landlord McLeskey; and the VBDA on March 21, 2023 and March 11, 2025.

Account 7:  Taylor Franklin (The Franklin Group)

City money for The Canopy, a Franklin Group project, and Attainable Workforce Housing grants to two Franklin Group projects, approved while Taylor Franklin sat on the VBDA.  The VBDA gave only first-year estimates for the grants, so they stay out of the balance.  Details:  The Franklin Group.

DateEntryDescriptionOwedPromised (up to)Balance
June 18, 20247-1$1,000,000 from the City’s General Fund to TFJG Canopy, LLC for the traffic signal at Laskin Road and Winwood Drive serving The Canopy.  The developer asked for it.161,000,0001,000,000
October 14, 20257-2Grand Lake Senior Apartments (Grand Lakes, LP), estimated first-year grant17188,5031,000,000
October 14, 20257-3The Silo Apartments (The Silo Apts., LP), estimated first-year grant17216,1791,000,000
Balance owed to the public404,682$1,000,000

Voted for it:  The Canopy, June 18, 2024 (11-0):  Worth Remick (moved), Amelia Ross-Hammond (seconded), Mayor Bobby Dyer, Vice Mayor Rosemary Wilson, Michael Berlucchi, Barbara Henley, David Hutcheson, Jennifer Rouse, Joash Schulman, Chris Taylor, and Sabrina Wooten.  Grants:  VBDA, October 14, 2025, 8-0-1.  Akhil Jain moved and Guenter Weissenseel seconded Grand Lakes; William Brunke moved and Mike Standing seconded The Silo.

Helped get it:  Remick works for Colliers, which leases the office and retail space at The Canopy for the Franklin Group.  He disclosed that in an October 10, 2023 letter, then moved the money.16

Account 8:  Ryan Turner (TST Tactical Defense Solutions)

Ryan Turner is TST’s CEO and CFO.  On September 8, 2026, the VBDA approved the amended deal, 8-0, after TST asked for up to $500,000 more from the VBDA in case the pond costs run over.18

DateEntryDescriptionOwedBalance
December 9, 20258-116 acres in Corporate Landing, 11 of them wetlands, for no cash.  TST builds a stormwater pond instead, which also serves its own site.  The deed will recite $1,000,000, the VBDA’s own price of $200,000 for each of the 5 usable acres; the assessor lists VBDA land at $0.18191,000,0001,000,000
December 9, 20258-2EDIP Part A grant from the VBDA ($283,000 for capital investment, $225,000 for jobs) for TST’s move onto 16 acres in Corporate Landing19508,0001,508,000
Balance owed to the public$1,508,000

Voted for it:  VBDA, December 9, 2025, 9-0, on both the land and the grant:  Guenter Weissenseel moved and David Weiner seconded the land; Weiner moved and Penny Morgan seconded the grant.  Also voting ‘aye’: Chairman Lisa Murphy, William Brunke, Eric Keplinger, Michael Harris, Esmel Meeks, and Mike Standing.  At the same meeting, the minutes record Vice Mayor Rosemary Wilson saying that “the general public feels that the Authority is giving land away in these instances.”19

Account 9:  Mike Standing (CLM Watermans Hotel and Waves 18, LLC)

Through CLM Watermans Hotel, LLC.  Mike Standing’s company is turning the Ramada at 2809 Atlantic Avenue into a $19 million Hotel Indigo, with up to $5,000,000 of the cost covered by state Tourism Development Financing.  Council reappointed Standing to the VBDA in August 2024.  The $5,000,000 stays out of the balance because it is paid only as the hotel produces new taxes.  Standing is also the registered agent of Waves 18, LLC with the State Corporation Commission.  That company received VBDA land in the Atlantic Park settlement, on a deed Chairman Lisa Murphy signed.

DateEntryDescriptionOwedPromised (up to)Balance
June 16, 20269-1Tourism gap financing for the Hotel Indigo at 2809 Atlantic Avenue:  the gap the state and City cover from the hotel’s new taxes after it opens205,000,0000
April 14, 20269-21.842 acres of VBDA land south of 18th Street, deeded to Waves 18, LLC as part of the Atlantic Park settlement.  Assessed at $9,657,900; the deed recites $5,000,000.214,657,9004,657,900
Balance owed to the public5,000,000$4,657,900

Voted for it:  VBDA, June 9, 2026, 8-0-1:  Penny Morgan moved and Eric Keplinger seconded; Akhil Jain abstained.  City Council, June 16, 2026 (9-0):  Worth Remick (moved), Amelia Ross-Hammond (seconded), Mayor Bobby Dyer, Vice Mayor Rosemary Wilson, Barbara Henley, David Hutcheson, Cal Jackson-Green, Jennifer Rouse, and Joash Schulman.  Michael Berlucchi and Stacy Cummings were absent.  The land:  VBDA, March 10, 2026, 4-0, with three commissioners abstaining:  Michael Harris (moved), Penny Morgan (seconded), Chairman Lisa Murphy, and Don Horsley.  Only 4 of the 11 commissioners approved it.  Asked whether the land would go back on the tax rolls, Deputy City Attorney Christopher Boynton said it would be taxed as its current use, surface parking.6

Account 10:  Bruce Thompson (Gold Key | PHR)

Through Thirty-First Street, L.C.  In a 2000 referendum, 58 percent of voters wanted this land kept as a park.  The City put nearly $32 million into the 31st Street project for the garage, park, and land.  Six years after buying the land from the VBDA, Gold Key | PHR sold the Hilton for $36 million.  Gold Key’s own vice president for development, Bryan Cuffee, sat on the VBDA from September 2011.

DateEntryDescriptionOwedBalance
June 14, 201210-1Public land at 31st Street under the Hilton and Neptune Park, two parcels, sold by the VBDA to Thompson’s Thirty-First Street, L.C. for $3,662,738.  The City Assessor valued the land at $11,600,000.227,937,2627,937,262
Balance owed to the public$7,937,262

Voted for it:  The VBDA’s 2012 minutes are not online, so the vote is not yet listed.

Helped get it:  VBDA Chairman John W. Richardson signed the deed.

Part II:  Residents paid, builders profited

Development decisions where the public paid to fix a builder’s problem and the builder kept its profit.

Account 11:  HomeFed Corporation (Christian Foulger, president)

Through HOFD Ashville Park, LLC.

DateEntryDescriptionOwedBalance
July 3, 201811-1Ashville Park drainage fix after homes in Villages A and B flooded.  The City pays 100% of $11,122,796, including $7,247,000 of on-site work assigned to the developer.  The developer pays $0, though the first plan offered had it paying $3.1 million.  It still gets its lot-size changes.2311,122,79611,122,796
August 7, 201811-2$1,000,000 moved out of Eastern Shore Drive Drainage Phase I, another flooding neighborhood, to pay for it2411,122,796
Balance owed to the public$11,122,796

Voted for it:  July 3, 2018 (9-0):  Barbara Henley (moved), Bobby Dyer (seconded), Ben Davenport, Mayor Louis Jones, Shannon Kane, John Moss, John Uhrin, Rosemary Wilson, and Vice Mayor Jim Wood.  August 7, 2018 transfer (9-0):  Wood (moved), Uhrin (seconded), Jessica Abbott, Davenport, Dyer, Henley, Jones, Moss, and Wilson.

Helped get it:  Eddie Bourdon prepared HOFD’s August 2018 proffer agreement.  His family sold 116.5 acres to Sandler for Ashville Park in 2004, on deeds he prepared.25

Account 12:  Richard Burroughs and Charles F. Burroughs III

Through Princess Anne Village, LLC.  The land was wetlands that drained the area; the builder profits from filling them, and residents pay to drain what the wetlands drained before.

DateEntryDescriptionOwedPromised (up to)Balance
January 21, 202512-1Princess Anne Village cost participation agreement:  the City pays for a 5-by-6-foot box culvert the developer builds through its 89-home subdivision, on farmland and wetlands below the Green Line that Council rezoned January 18, 2022 with the City as co-applicant.  Staff said the pipe was “not on Public Works’ replacement schedule.”26272,341,6400
Balance owed to the public2,341,640$0

Voted for it:  January 21, 2025 (9-0, consent agenda):  Barbara Henley (moved), Amelia Ross-Hammond (seconded), Mayor Bobby Dyer, Michael Berlucchi, Stacy Cummings, David Hutcheson, Cal Jackson-Green, Worth Remick, and Joash Schulman.  Jennifer Rouse and Rosemary Wilson were absent.

Helped get it:  Attorney R.J. Nutter (Troutman Pepper) represented Princess Anne Village.  Deputy City Manager Amanda Jarratt and Public Works Director L.J. Hansen briefed Council on July 9, 2024, when the City’s share was $1,727,000.

Votes behind the balances, by official

Each official who moved, seconded, or voted ‘aye’ is credited with the full amount, because it needed their vote.  These totals overlap, so they do not add up to the total owed.  Part II includes the $2,341,640 Princess Anne Village cap.

OfficialSeatGave awayPromised (up to)Residents paid (Part II)
Bobby DyerMayor$18,664,469$18,800,000$13,464,436
Rosemary WilsonVice Mayor$18,573,469$18,800,000$11,122,796
Amelia Ross-HammondCouncil$18,499,469$18,800,000$2,341,640
Michael BerlucchiCouncil$17,809,300$13,800,000$2,341,640
Joash SchulmanCouncil$17,809,300$18,800,000$2,341,640
David HutchesonCouncil$17,809,300$18,800,000$2,341,640
Stacy CummingsCouncil$16,809,300$13,800,000$2,341,640
Cal Jackson-GreenCouncil$16,809,300$18,800,000$2,341,640
Jennifer RouseCouncil$17,809,300$18,800,000
Barbara HenleyCouncil$2,022,369$5,000,000$13,464,436
Louis JonesFormer mayor$1,022,369$11,122,796
Shannon KaneFormer Council$1,022,369$11,122,796
John MossFormer Council$1,022,369$11,122,796
John UhrinFormer Council$1,022,369$11,122,796
Jim WoodFormer vice mayor$1,022,369$11,122,796
Ben DavenportFormer Council$764,169$11,122,796
Lisa MurphyVBDA chairman$9,496,437.77$5,000,000
Penny MorganVBDA$9,165,900$5,000,000
Michael E. HarrisVBDA$7,657,900$5,000,000
Donald H. HorsleyVBDA$7,657,900
Guenter H. WeissenseelVBDA$4,057,999.60$5,000,000
Worth RemickCouncil$1,000,000$5,000,000$2,341,640
Michael J. StandingVBDA$3,257,999.60
Eric KeplingerVBDA$2,308,000$5,000,000
W. Taylor FranklinVBDA$1,749,999.60
Akhil JainVBDA$1,749,999.60
William BrunkeVBDA$1,508,000$5,000,000
David WeinerVBDA$1,508,000$5,000,000
Michael HarrisVBDA$1,508,000
Esmel MeeksVBDA$1,508,000
Sabrina WootenFormer Council$1,074,000
Chris TaylorFormer Council$1,000,000
Dorothy (Dot) WoodVBDA$330,537.77
Will SessomsFormer mayor$258,200
Brad MartinFormer Council$258,200
Patrick ShulerVBDA$5,000,000

Notes and sources:

  1. City Council minutes, August 11, 2026, Item K.1 (ordinance and term sheet § 3), PDF pages 97–98 and 105–106; City Real Estate Assessor, FY 2026/27 assessments, GPINs 1494-34-4919 ($9,160,000), 1494-52-3434 ($415,300), 1494-13-7202 ($432,000), and 1494-03-5237 ($682,000).  ↩
  2. City Council minutes, August 11, 2026, Item K.1 (term sheet), PDF pages 103, 107, and 108.  ↩
  3. City Council minutes, August 11, 2026, Item K.1 (term sheet § 10(a)), PDF pages 110–111.  ↩
  4. City Council minutes, August 11, 2026, Item K.1, PDF page 97.  ↩
  5. City Attorney’s FOIA response to Councilmember Chris Taylor, October 25, 2024 (copy on file).  ↩
  6. Virginia Beach Development Authority minutes, March 10, 2026, Item 3, PDF page 4.  ↩
  7. Virginia Beach Development Authority minutes, June 13, 2025, Items 4 and 5, PDF page 4; Virginia Economic Development Partnership, Commonwealth’s Development Opportunity Fund report to the General Assembly; Virginia Beach Development Authority, Annual Report 2024–2025.  ↩
  8. City Council minutes, October 7, 2014, Item 64187, PDF page 57; deeds, instruments 201500072653 and 201500072655, recorded July 31, 2015 (assessments on the deed cover sheets).  ↩
  9. City Council minutes, May 17, 2016, Item 65992, PDF page 92; deed, instrument 201700017847.  ↩
  10. City Council minutes, May 17, 2016, Item 65992, PDF page 92, and September 20, 2016, Item 66347, PDF pages 146–148; deed, instrument 201700017850, recorded March 2, 2017.  ↩
  11. City Council minutes, December 11, 2018, Item 68743, PDF page 113; deed, instrument 201900044644, recorded June 4, 2019.  ↩
  12. Virginia Beach Development Authority minutes, May 12, 2026, Item 5, PDF page 5.  ↩
  13. Virginia Beach Development Authority minutes, October 20, 2020 (copy on file), with Lisa Murphy’s list of the applicants or landlords who use Willcox & Savage.  ↩
  14. Virginia Beach Development Authority minutes, March 21, 2023.  ↩
  15. Virginia Beach Development Authority minutes, March 11, 2025, PDF page 9.  ↩
  16. City Council minutes, June 18, 2024, Item 75854, PDF pages 142 and 145–148, including Councilman Worth Remick’s disclosure letter of October 10, 2023.  ↩
  17. Virginia Beach Development Authority minutes, October 14, 2025, Items 6 and 7, PDF pages 6–7; City briefing, October 14, 2025, Attainable Workforce Housing grants.  ↩
  18. Virginia Beach Development Authority minutes, September 8, 2026, Items 6 and 7 (voted together), PDF pages 6–7.  ↩
  19. Virginia Beach Development Authority minutes (draft), December 9, 2025, Item 6, PDF pages 6–7.  ↩
  20. City Council minutes, June 16, 2026, Item 78449, PDF pages 107–109; Virginia Beach Development Authority minutes, June 9, 2026, Item 8, PDF pages 5–6.  ↩
  21. Deed, instrument 202603018526, recorded April 27, 2026 (assessed value and consideration on the cover sheet), GPINs 2427-17-2254, 2427-17-2099, and 2427-17-0169; Virginia State Corporation Commission records for Waves 18, LLC.  ↩
  22. Special warranty deed, City of Virginia Beach Development Authority to Thirty-First Street, L.C., June 14, 2012, Instrument No. 201200068488 (re-recorded as Instrument No. 201200078663), GPINs 2428-02-7323 and 2428-02-7087, consideration $3,662,738; Mike Hixenbaugh, “Developer buys land, park by 31st Street Hilton hotel,” The Virginian-Pilot, June 23, 2012 (the two parcels “are valued at a combined $11.6 million, according to the city assessor’s office”; a 2003 clause let Thompson buy them at their 2003 value, $3.5 million, adjusted for inflation); Alissa Skelton, “Bruce Thompson sells two hotels at the Virginia Beach Oceanfront and buys another,” The Virginian-Pilot, September 7, 2018 (City’s $32 million; 2000 referendum); WYDaily, September 19, 2018 (Hilton sold for $36 million); Kerry Dougherty, “Special Feature:  Connections and Conflicts,” October 11, 2018 (Cuffee).  ↩
  23. City Council minutes, July 3, 2018, Item 68252 (City Manager’s briefing), PDF pages 11–14, and Item 68265 (ordinance and term sheet, “CPA Proposal 3, Alternative Version”), PDF pages 43–46.  ↩
  24. City Council minutes, August 7, 2018, Item 68355, PDF pages 169–170.  ↩
  25. City Council minutes, August 7, 2018, Item 68366, PDF pages 190 and 202; deeds, instruments 200400140052 and 200400140053, recorded September 1, 2004.  ↩
  26. City Council agenda, January 21, 2025, PDF page 14.  ↩
  27. City Council minutes, January 21, 2025, Item 76574, PDF pages 118–119; City Council briefing, July 9, 2024 (Princess Anne Village Stormwater), PDF pages 2–4 and 12; City Council minutes, January 18, 2022, Item 72439, PDF pages 172–176.  ↩

Last updated November 20, 2026.

Have records or evidence about this?  Email keepvbabovewater@gmail.com.

Comments

Leave a Reply