Atlantic Park: $1 a Year, a State Law, and the Developers’ Money

Flow chart: how Atlantic Park connects to Del. Barry Knight, Del. Alex Askew, City Council, the VBDA, TowneBank, and the surf park bonds

* Based on James C. Sherlock’s eleven-part investigation, “Atlantic Park,” on Bacon’s Rebellion, September 9 to September 20, 2024.  New records added by Keep Virginia Beach Above Water.

Atlantic Park is the surf park, concert hall, shops, and apartments on the old Dome site at the Oceanfront, 18th to 20th Streets.  The developers are Venture Realty Group (Michael A. “Mike” Culpepper and Donna MacMillan Whitaker), Steven W. Bishard, W.M. Jordan Company, Douglas D. Ellis, and Pharrell Williams, through Venture Waves, LLC and Atlantic Park, Inc.1

The City never asked for proposals.  It picked the team in 2017, leased it nearly 13 acres for $1 a year, and borrowed for the parts it owns.  The City’s share was about $96 million in a 2019 plan; Sherlock now counts more than $300 million.  The developers’ promised $230 million fell to about $116 million.2

The late Del. Barry Knight carried the 2020 law that let the City set up an authority to borrow for the project against state sales tax.  The developers gave him $31,750.3

Standing conflicts:
Still standing today

  • Land for $1 a year:  The VBDA leases the Dome site to the developers for 60 years at $1 a year, plus two 20-year renewals at $1.  Sherlock values the land at $40 million and the 400 City-built parking spaces with it at about $12 million ($30,000 each).2
  • The VBDA pays the developer:  Over $62 million in draws to Venture Waves (January 2024 to August 2026), plus a March 10, 2026 settlement of $3 million and 1.842 acres of public land.4
  • Council is the authority:  Under Knight’s law, all eleven Council members sit on the board of the authority that borrows for the project they fund.5
  • Mike Standing:  While on the VBDA, Standing was named “a principal of an entity with interest in Venture Waves, LLC,” the VBDA’s own tenant, and he is an officer of the Atlantic Park Surf Club with the Bishards.6
  • Lisa Murphy’s conflicts:  Lisa Murphy, a partner at Willcox & Savage, represents developers in front of the Planning Commission and City Council while sitting as VBDA chairman.  She voted ‘aye’ on the 2026 settlement and the 2026 state money.7
  • TowneBank:  An Atlantic Park lender.  Its Virginia Beach board includes investor Douglas D. Ellis, VBDA Commissioner Akhil Jain, Bishard’s partner Chris Ettel, and Herbert A. Culpepper of Pungo Realty, of Mike Culpepper’s family.8
  • Worth Remick:  Councilman Worth Remick works for Colliers, which serves other properties of Venture Waves’ members, and voted ‘aye’ on their valet franchise.9
  • State money in 2026:  $5 million through the VBDA, with no local match, after a request by Del. Alex Askew.10
Flow chart: how Atlantic Park connects to Del. Barry Knight, Del. Alex Askew, City Council, the VBDA, TowneBank, and the surf park bonds

Del. Barry Knight:  The bill

A 2019 law let Virginia Beach keep state sales tax from an Oceanfront entertainment project to pay bonds.  Knight voted ‘aye’ on February 22, 2019.11

Knight’s HB 120 (2020) rewrote it for Atlantic Park.  A “community development authority” could issue the bonds and pay them with the sales tax, Council could sit as its board, and the tax break would run 20 years past completion instead of ending in 2039.5

The House voted it down 44 to 51 on February 10, 2020, then passed it 75 to 24 the next day.  The Senate passed it 36 to 2 on February 26.  Knight also voted ‘aye’ on Askew’s HB 1825 on the same bonds (January 20, 2021, 80 to 19).12

The money, by date:

  • September 12, 2019:  Mike Culpepper and John Gibson of Venture Realty give $500 each.  Knight files HB 120 on December 16, 2019.
  • September 3, 2021:  Donna Whitaker of Venture Realty gives $2,500.  Four days later, Council uses Knight’s law to create the authority.
  • September 14 and 15, 2022:  Douglas Ellis gives $5,000 and Venture Realty Group gives $5,000.  That week the state approves up to $75 million in surf park bonds (September 13) and the VBDA backs them (September 20).
  • September 15 and 21, 2023:  Venture Realty Group gives $5,000 and W.M. Jordan Company gives $10,000, after the bonds sell March 31, 2023.
  • Other years:  Douglas Ellis ($250, August 27, 2015), Bishard Development Corporation ($1,000, September 17, 2015), John Gibson ($500, August 24, 2025), and W.M. Jordan ($1,500, September 3, 2025).3

The law:  Legislators may not take anything that “reasonably tends to influence” them, but reported campaign money is exempt.13  So there is no limit on what a developer can give the legislator carrying its bill.

Mike Culpepper:  The developer’s attorney

Mike Culpepper is Venture Realty Group’s managing partner and in-house attorney, named on every Atlantic Park disclosure to Council since January 8, 2019.1

In 2022 the developers could not get bank loans for the surf park and missed a June 1 deadline that let the VBDA cancel the deal.  It did not.  The surf park went to a North Carolina charity, P3 Foundation, to borrow tax-free state bonds.  Culpepper pitched the Virginia Small Business Financing Authority on September 13, 2022, and it approved up to $75 million at up to 12 percent.  When a VBDA commissioner asked about P3 a week later, staff passed the question to Culpepper, and the VBDA backed the bonds.14

Culpepper later said tax-free bonds had been the plan “for more than two years.”  The bonds sold March 31, 2023:  $63.575 million at 9 to 10.25 percent, about $207 million with interest, for a $41 million surf lagoon.  Developer team members bought the riskier second-tier bonds.15

Culpepper family:  Mike Culpepper’s parents are Herbert A. Culpepper Sr. and Carolyn Adair Austin Culpepper; his brother is Herbert A. Culpepper Jr.16  Both Herberts list Pungo Realty on their campaign gifts.  On November 9, 2006, Herbert Sr. deeds neighboring Back Bay Commons lots to Mike and Herbert Jr.17  In 2009 Mike buys his Pinewood Park home from Bishard Development Corporation for $540,000.18

The Culpeppers have given Knight $11,000 since 2014:  $10,500 from the two Herberts, including $1,000 on September 3, 2021, four days before Council created the authority, and $500 from Mike.  Mike also gave Askew $500 on September 29, 2021.3, 19

City Council:  $1 a year and the authority

In 2018, Councilmen John Uhrin and Louis Jones, who led the selection panel, asked the City Manager to raise the developers’ return.  On November 21, 2018, he answered that staff’s number was “a more acceptable rate of return.”  Their numbers went into the December 21, 2018 term sheet.  Uhrin, who had lost his seat, left a week later.20

  • January 15, 2019:  Council approves the term sheet 9-1, on a motion by David Nygaard, seconded by Rosemary Wilson, with Culpepper speaking for it.  The only ‘nay’ is Jessica Abbott.  Voting ‘aye’:  Bobby Dyer, Barbara Henley, Louis Jones, Shannon Kane, David Nygaard, Aaron Rouse, Rosemary Wilson, Jim Wood, and Sabrina Wooten.21  Tim Costen of The Costen Companies had given Dyer $3,000 (November 2, 2018), and W.M. Jordan and Tim Costen gave Rouse $1,000 each in August and September 2018.22
  • November 19, 2019:  Council approves the development agreement and $9 million, 10-0, on a motion by Guy Tower, seconded by Jim Wood, with Culpepper speaking for it.  Voting ‘aye’:  Jessica Abbott, Michael Berlucchi, Bobby Dyer, Barbara Henley, Louis Jones, Aaron Rouse, Guy Tower, Rosemary Wilson, Jim Wood, and Sabrina Wooten.23  Wilson had received $500 from Bishard Development Corporation (July 29, 2019) and $1,000 from W.M. Jordan (August 31, 2019).24
  • September 7, 2021:  Council creates the authority by consent, 10-0, on a motion by Louis Jones, seconded by Rosemary Wilson.  Voting ‘aye’:  Michael Berlucchi, Bobby Dyer, Barbara Henley, Rocky Holcomb, Louis Jones, John Moss, Aaron Rouse, Guy Tower, Rosemary Wilson, and Sabrina Wooten.  The VBDA is the only landowner on the petition.25
  • November 16, 2021:  Council approves the first amendment and $17,729,147 from the General Fund balance for offsite work, 9-1, on a motion by Louis Jones, seconded by Linwood Branch, with Culpepper speaking for it.  The only ‘nay’ is John Moss.  Voting ‘aye’:  Linwood Branch, Bobby Dyer, Barbara Henley, Rocky Holcomb, Louis Jones, Aaron Rouse, Guy Tower, Rosemary Wilson, and Sabrina Wooten.26
  • April 5, 2022:  Council amends the authority’s ordinance 10-1 over three speakers who oppose it, on a motion by Linwood Branch, seconded by Guy Tower.  The only ‘nay’ is Sabrina Wooten.  Voting ‘aye’:  Michael Berlucchi, Linwood Branch, Bobby Dyer, Barbara Henley, Rocky Holcomb, Louis Jones, John Moss, Aaron Rouse, Guy Tower, and Rosemary Wilson.27
  • September 20, 2022:  Council lets Atlantic Park build patios, steps, walls, and a balcony on City streets, 10-0 by consent, on a motion by Rosemary Wilson, seconded by John Moss.  John K. Bishard gives Councilman Rocky Holcomb $1,500 that day.28
  • April 1, 2025:  Council gives Venture Waves a five-year valet franchise on 18th Street, 20th Street, and Arctic Avenue, with no franchise fee, 11-0 by consent, on a motion by Rosemary Wilson, seconded by Michael Berlucchi.  Councilman Worth Remick files a disclosure that he works for Colliers, which serves other properties of Venture Waves’ members, and votes ‘aye.’  W.M. Jordan gives Mayor Dyer $5,000 four weeks later (April 30, 2025).29, 30

The City’s planned share grew from $37.5 million in 2019 to $95.6 million in 2020 and $153 million by 2024, all 10-0 except a $9.2 million land purchase.  With bond interest and the authority’s 2023 bonds, it tops $300 million.31

The law:  Local officials may not take anything that tends to influence their votes, but reported campaign money is exempt.32  Sherlock urges Council to require members to disclose any donor over $500 before voting on that donor’s business.33

Development Authority:  Draws, a settlement, and state money

The VBDA owns the land and pays the developer to build the City’s concert hall (“The Dome by Rutter Mills”) and offsite work; the City pays the VBDA back.  The VBDA’s minutes list over $62 million in draws to Venture Waves from January 2024 through August 2026.4

Digging the surf lagoon hit groundwater high in iron and arsenic.  State regulators traced brown water in a Lake Holly cove to the dig, and pumping stopped.  The developer said the City, as landowner, should pay the roughly $1 million cleanup.34

  • March 10, 2026:  The VBDA settles, giving Venture Waves $3 million in City cashA and about 1.842 acres south of 18th Street between Arctic and Pacific Avenues, three parking lots set aside for Phase 2.  The Virginian-Pilot puts the land at $5 million; the minutes give no value.34  The deal also says the City owes no local match on state money.  Michael Harris moves it and Penny Morgan seconds.  It passes with four votes:  Chairman Lisa Murphy, Michael Harris, Don Horsley, and Penny Morgan.7
  • September 8, 2026:  The VBDA accepts the $5 million in state money “designed to be passed through to Atlantic Park for purposes of development expansion,” on a motion by Patrick Shuler, seconded by Martin Joseph.  Voting ‘aye’:  Lisa Murphy, William Brunke, Guenter Weissenseel, Don Horsley, Esmel Meeks, Patrick Shuler, and Martin Joseph.35

Mike Standing:  A commissioner inside the developer’s circle.  Mike Standing (Michael J. Standing Jr.) sat on the VBDA from February 2019 until spring 2026.  On July 3, 2024, the State Corporation Commission lists “Michael Standing, Jr.” as treasurer and a director of the new Atlantic Park Surf Club, with Joseph LaMontagne as president and Steven W. Bishard and John K. Bishard as officers.36  On August 20, 2024, on the nomination of Rosemary Wilson, Council reappoints Standing to the VBDA, 10-0.37  On January 21, 2025, the VBDA’s disclosure to Council answers “Yes” to whether a City official has an interest:  “Michael J. Standing is a principal of an entity with interest in Venture Waves, LLC and serves on the VBDA Board of Commissioners.”6  On April 8, 2025, Standing writes that he has “a financial interest in the overall Atlantic Park project.”38

The law:  No officer of a local agency may have a personal interest in a contract with that agency.39  The VBDA’s development agreement and $1 lease with Venture Waves are VBDA contracts.  An official with a personal interest in a transaction must step aside, may not vote or sit in closed session on it, and must disclose the interest in the agency’s records.40  No disclosure by Murphy appears in the March 10 or September 8, 2026 minutes.7, 35

Del. Alex Askew:  $5 million from the state

Del. Alex Askew of Virginia Beach carried HB 1825 (2021), letting the Atlantic Park bonds run as long as the sales tax break.41  In 2026 he asked for $10 million “for the development of Atlantic Park.”  The final budget gave $5 million for “engineering, infrastructure, maintenance, and other related costs.”10  Mike Culpepper gave Askew $500 on September 29, 2021, three weeks after Council created the authority.19

TowneBank:  Lender and board

At the March 31, 2023 closing, Venture Realty said “additional supporting construction lending was provided by TowneBank.”  Fulton Bank led the main loan with Old Point National Bank and Dollar Bank.42

TowneBank’s Virginia Beach board includes Atlantic Park investor Douglas D. Ellis (Ellis-Gibson Development, merged into Venture Realty in 2016, and VBDA assistant secretary in 2010), VBDA Commissioner Akhil Jain, Bishard’s partner Chris Ettel, and Herbert A. Culpepper of Pungo Realty, of the developer’s family.8, 43

Who is behind Atlantic Park:

Council disclosures name Atlantic Park, Inc.; Venture Realty Group and Venture Realty Group 1, LLC; Venture Waves, LLC; Donna MacMillan Whitaker; Michael A. Culpepper; John L. Gibson III; Bruce A. Berlin; Elizabeth Matulenas; Matthew L. Lafler; Douglas D. Ellis; Steven D. Green; Fiona Sadler; W.M. Jordan Company; John R. Lawson; H2O Investments, LLC; Joe LaMontagne; The Costen Companies; Tim Costen; Pharrell Williams; Bishard Development Corp.; Steven W. Bishard; John K. Bishard; and Robert A. Deacon.  By March 18, 2025 they add Rhema Waves, LLC, Bishard Investments, LLC, and Bishard CFO Thomas Lewis.1

The surf park is owned by P3 VB Holdings, LLC, a Virginia shell formed October 5, 2022 by P3 Foundation of North Carolina, whose president and secretary work for Jones Lang LaSalle, a member of the development team.44

Campaign money from the Atlantic Park team

A line through a name means the person no longer holds that office.

  • Del. Barry Knight:  $31,750 (2015 to 2025; see above)
  • Mayor Bobby Dyer:  $3,000 from Tim Costen (November 2, 2018, before the term sheet vote); $5,000 from W.M. Jordan (April 30, 2025, four weeks after the valet vote); and $2,000 from Douglas D. Ellis (April 13, 2023 and July 2, 2024)30
  • Councilman Michael Berlucchi:  $7,500 from Douglas Ellis, John Gibson, Donna Whitaker, and Bruce Berlin, 2023 to 2026, including Whitaker ($1,500, October 28, 2024), five months before he seconded the valet franchise, and Ellis ($1,000, March 5, 2026) and Gibson ($1,000, March 18, 2026), the month of the VBDA settlement45
  • Councilmember Rosemary Wilson:  $1,500 before her November 19, 2019 vote (Bishard Development, $500, July 29, 2019; W.M. Jordan, $1,000, August 31, 2019), and $2,500 from Douglas D. Ellis (January 13, 2023)24
  • Sen. Aaron Rouse (District 22):  $2,000 before his January 15, 2019 vote (W.M. Jordan, $1,000, August 22, 2018; Tim Costen, $1,000, September 28, 2018)22
  • Councilman Rocky Holcomb:  $1,500 from John K. Bishard on September 20, 2022, the day of his Atlantic Park vote (now Sheriff)28
  • Councilman John Uhrin:  $1,000 from Priority Title and Escrow (Atlantic Park partner Priority Title/H2O Investments) on September 6, 2018, two months before he and Louis Jones pressed for a higher developer return20
  • Del. Alex Askew:  $500 (Mike Culpepper, September 29, 2021)19

The $3 million settlement is Account 2 in Owed to the Public, the running ledger of public money and land given to private parties.

Related posts:

Taken from the public:

  1. $3,000,000 in City cash to Mike Culpepper (Venture Realty Group), through Venture Waves, LLC. The VBDA’s Atlantic Park settlement after the surf lagoon dig hit arsenic-laden groundwater.  The 1.842 acres of public land in the same settlement, and the $1-a-year lease, are not yet counted.  VBDA minutes, March 10, 2026, Item 3, PDF page 4.  Ledger PM-0006.  Running total:  $3,000,000.  ↩

Total in this post:  $3,000,000.  Total owed to the public, all posts:  $23,866,802.37.

Notes and sources:

  1. Atlantic Park disclosure statements to City Council:  City Council minutes, January 8, 2019 (disclosure), PDF page 3; November 19, 2019, Item 69790; November 16, 2021, Item 72235; City Council agenda, January 21, 2025, PDF page 90; March 18, 2025 disclosure.  ↩
  2. James C. Sherlock, “Atlantic Park,” Part 3 and Part 11, Bacon’s Rebellion, September 2024.  ↩
  3. Virginia Department of Elections, Friends of Barry D. Knight campaign finance reports, 2014–2025.  ↩
  4. VBDA minutes, January 2024 through August 2026 (monthly approvals of Venture Waves construction draws).  ↩
  5. HB 120 (2020), Chapter 467, Acts of Assembly, approved March 25, 2020 (bill history).  ↩
  6. City Council agenda, January 21, 2025, Atlantic Park item, VBDA and Atlantic Park, Inc. disclosure statements, PDF pages 90–91.  ↩
  7. VBDA minutes, March 10, 2026, Item 3, PDF page 4.  ↩
  8. TowneBank, Virginia Beach regional board of directors (bank website, November 2026).  ↩
  9. City Council minutes, April 1, 2025, Item 76859, PDF page 178; Councilman Worth Remick disclosure under Va. Code § 2.2-3115(I), April 1, 2025, PDF pages 182–185.  ↩
  10. Virginia budget, 2026 session, Item 101 #7h (Askew request) and Item 101 #5c (conference report); VBDA minutes, September 8, 2026, PDF page 7.  ↩
  11. SB 1790 (2019), Chapter 793, Acts of Assembly (bill history and votes).  ↩
  12. HB 120 (2020) votes; HB 1825 (2021) votes.  ↩
  13. Va. Code § 30-103(5) (General Assembly Conflicts of Interests Act).  ↩
  14. James C. Sherlock, “Atlantic Park,” Part 7 and Part 10, Bacon’s Rebellion, September 2024.  ↩
  15. James C. Sherlock, “Atlantic Park,” Part 8 and Part 10, Bacon’s Rebellion, September 2024.  ↩
  16. Virginia Beach Circuit Court marriage register:  Michael Austin Culpepper, instrument 200300104520 (license July 9, 2003); Herbert Ashburn Culpepper Jr., instrument 200002591820 (license April 12, 2000).  Both name the parents Herbert Ashburn Culpepper Sr. and Carolyn Adair Austin.  ↩
  17. Deeds of gift, instruments 200600171641 and 200600171642, recorded November 14, 2006, Virginia Beach Circuit Court.  ↩
  18. Deed, instrument 200900123406, recorded October 21, 2009, Virginia Beach Circuit Court.  ↩
  19. Virginia Department of Elections, Friends of Alex Askew campaign finance reports, 2021.  ↩
  20. James C. Sherlock, “Atlantic Park,” Part 4, Bacon’s Rebellion, September 2024.  Virginia Department of Elections, Friends of John Uhrin campaign finance reports, 2018.  ↩
  21. City Council minutes, January 15, 2019, Item 68818, PDF pages 78–79.  ↩
  22. James C. Sherlock, “Atlantic Park,” Part 2, Bacon’s Rebellion, September 2024.  Virginia Department of Elections campaign finance reports (Dyer, Rouse), 2018.  ↩
  23. City Council minutes, November 19, 2019, Item 69790, PDF page 68.  ↩
  24. Virginia Department of Elections, Rosemary Wilson campaign finance reports, 2019–2023.  ↩
  25. City Council minutes, September 7, 2021, Item 71976, PDF page 57.  ↩
  26. City Council minutes, November 16, 2021, Item 72235, PDF page 131.  ↩
  27. City Council minutes, April 5, 2022, Item 72675, PDF page 83.  ↩
  28. City Council minutes, September 20, 2022, Item 73301, PDF page 119; Virginia Department of Elections, Rocky Holcomb campaign finance reports, 2022.  ↩
  29. City Council minutes, April 1, 2025, Item 76859 (ordinance and summary of terms), PDF pages 178–185.  ↩
  30. Virginia Department of Elections, Bobby Dyer campaign finance reports, 2018–2025.  ↩
  31. James C. Sherlock, “Atlantic Park,” Part 3 and Part 4, Bacon’s Rebellion, September 2024.  ↩
  32. Va. Code § 2.2-3103(5) (State and Local Government Conflict of Interests Act).  ↩
  33. James C. Sherlock, “Atlantic Park,” Part 6, Bacon’s Rebellion, September 2024.  ↩
  34. Stacy Parker, “Virginia Beach proposes multi-million dollar settlement with surf park operator,” Virginian-Pilot, March 7, 2026 (Yahoo).  ↩
  35. VBDA minutes, September 8, 2026, PDF page 7.  ↩
  36. Virginia State Corporation Commission, Atlantic Park Surf Club, entity 11716836, formed July 3, 2024 (officers list).  ↩
  37. City Council minutes, August 20, 2024, Item 76046, PDF page 147.  ↩
  38. VBDA minutes, April 8, 2025 (Standing letter to the VBDA clerk).  ↩
  39. Va. Code § 2.2-3109(A).  ↩
  40. Va. Code § 2.2-3112(A); § 2.2-3115(F).  ↩
  41. HB 1825 (2021), Chapter 5, Acts of Assembly, approved March 1, 2021 (bill history).  ↩
  42. Venture Realty Group closing announcement, March 31, 2023 (Surf Park Central).  ↩
  43. VBDA 2010 Annual Report, officers page (copy on file).  ↩
  44. James C. Sherlock, “Atlantic Park,” Part 9, Bacon’s Rebellion, September 2024.  ↩
  45. Virginia Department of Elections, Michael Berlucchi campaign finance reports, 2023–2026.  ↩

Last updated November 20, 2026.

Have records or evidence about this?  Email keepvbabovewater@gmail.com.

Comments

Leave a Reply