Gold Key | PHR:  The Hotel Company on Both Sides of the VBDA

Gold lines are money.  Red lines are seats.

Gold Key | PHR, a/k/a PHR/GKR Holding Co., is Bruce Thompson’s Oceanfront hotel company, the developer behind the 31st Street Hilton, Neptune Park, and the Cavalier.1, 2

Gold Key’s biggest conflict:  its own vice president for development, Bryan Cuffee, sitting on the VBDA while the VBDA was Gold Key’s landlord at 31st Street and the agency paying out the Cavalier’s gap financing.3, 4

Gold lines are money.  Red lines are seats.
Gold lines are money.  Red lines are seats.

Standing conflicts:
Still standing today

  • Dam Neck Associates:  On March 4, 2025, on Rosemary Wilson’s motion, Council votes ‘aye’, 9-0, by consent, to rezone 872 and 1089 Dam Neck Road for Dam Neck Associates, LLC.  Its disclosure names Gold Key | PHR, Cheryl McLeskey, and The Franklin Group’s Franklin Johnston as affiliates.5  Earlier, on August 10, 2022, the Planning Commission votes 10-0 to recommend Dam Neck Associates’ application, with Don Horsley (now on the VBDA), David Weiner, and Holly Cuellar voting ‘aye’.6  The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service National Wetlands Inventory map shows 10.18 acres of vegetated wetland on the parcels, wetlands “afforded the greatest protection under state law.”7  By the 2025 vote, Thompson had given Wilson $9,000.8
  • Cadenz Development:  In summer 2025, Gold Key | PHR and McLeskey formed and invested in Cadenz Development & Construction Management, run by Bryan Cuffee.9
  • Lisa Murphy’s conflicts:  The VBDA chairman’s firm, Willcox & Savage, has counted Gold Key | PHR as a client.  Murphy’s own letter for the November 17, 2020 CARES Act awards lists Gold Key/PHR among nine applicants her firm serves.10  On October 20, 2020, Gold Key | PHR was landlord to four EDIP grant winners on Murphy’s list.11  Murphy voted ‘aye’ on May 12, 2026, to hand the Cavalier’s gap financing to its buyer.12
  • The voting system:  Gold Key’s Professional Hospitality Resources was the top donor, at $33,050, to Every Vote Counts VB, the 2025 committee pushing to end Virginia Beach’s district-only elections.  Linwood Branch’s family’s Lynn-Dee Motel gave it $20,000.13  Branch’s lawsuit was the reason Governor Glenn Youngkin gave for vetoing the district system on May 17, 2024.  The details are on our Bruce Thompson post.14
  • The money:  Thompson and Gold Key’s holding company have given eight sitting Council members $64,000.  The list is on our Bruce Thompson post.

31st Street and 42 Ocean:  Public land, Gold Key’s hotels

  • 2002:  Thompson’s Thirty-First Street, L.C. and the City plan a $50 million public-private project at 31st Street:  a hotel, shops, and a park.15  The VBDA leases the land to Thirty-First Street, L.C.4  Fifty-eight percent of voters had backed a 2000 referendum to keep the land a park; Council did not follow it.  The City put nearly $32 million into the $79 million project for the garage, park, and land.16
  • June 22, 2010:  Gold Key asks Council to amend the lease and development deal for a second hotel and more parking.  Bryan Cuffee speaks for Gold Key.  A resident objects to “charging only $2.25 a day to Bruce Thompson for prime parking spaces.”  John Moss, then a resident, calls it “special interest legislation.”4
  • June 22, 2010:  Council votes ‘aye’, 6-5.  Wilson votes ‘aye’ after disclosing that her husband was a principal in Goodman & Company, the accounting firm serving Thirty-First Street, L.C.  Mayor Will Sessoms votes ‘aye’ after disclosing that TowneBank financed the 31st Street Hilton.  The ‘nay’ votes are Rita Sweet Bellitto, Bill DeSteph, Harry Diezel, Bobby Dyer, and Louis Jones.4
  • September 2011:  Cuffee joins the VBDA.3
  • June 14, 2012:  The VBDA deeds the public land under the hotels, two parcels at 31st Street and Atlantic Avenue, to Thompson’s Thirty-First Street, L.C. for $3,662,738.  VBDA Chair John W. Richardson signs.17  The price was set by a 2003 clause letting Thompson buy the land at its 2003 value, $3.5 million, plus inflation.  The City Assessor valued the two parcels at $11.6 million.  The same sale freed the City from any duty to repay a $7 million loan Thompson took out in 2008 using the City-owned land as collateral.18A
  • 2013:  The City spends about $40 million on roads, a traffic circle, and utilities on Laskin Road around Thompson’s new $72 million 31Ocean project.16
  • 2015 to 2021:  TowneBank lends on Gold Key’s next oceanfront project, the Marriott and 42 Ocean condominiums at 4201 Atlantic Avenue:  $10,000,000 in 2015, $77,094,836 in 2016, $29,407,170 in 2019, and $70,000,000 in 2020, all to Oceanfront Investments, LLC, which Gold Key | PHR manages (some refinance earlier loans).19
  • September 2018:  Before the Council election, Thompson warns that “Gold Key PHR will sit on sidelines and wait and see what this election brings before investing another dime in the resort area.”  The same month the Pilot reports he has just bought the Days Inn at 2417 Atlantic Avenue and four properties across the street for more than $20 million.20
  • August 31, 2018:  Gold Key sells the Hilton for $36 million, Neptune Park with its shops and garage for $53.7 million, and the Hilton Garden Inn for $34.4 million.  Six years after buying the land from the VBDA for $3,662,738, Gold Key sells the Hilton for $36 million.  The VBDA still owns the garage’s parking and retail space.1
  • 2021:  The City lets the 42 Ocean condominium’s balconies and roof deck, and the Marriott’s landscaping, sit on City land for $1.  A second $1 agreement lets them build two sets of wooden stairs on the City’s “sandy beach.”  Gold Key | PHR’s chief investment officer, Robert M. Howard, signs for the companies; a designee of the City Manager signs for the City.21

Beach Quarters Inn:  The VBDA buys it, Gold Key leases it back

In 2002, Thompson sold the Beach Quarters Inn to the VBDA for $2.5 million and leased it back.  On September 21, 2010, his first day on the VBDA, Linwood Branch voted to pay $55,000 for elevator work at the inn.  A 2001 City Attorney opinion found Gold Key paid Branch’s family’s Lynn-Dee Motel referral fees of more than $10,000 a year.22

In 2017, Thompson’s attorney told Council that “Bruce Thompson has developed numerous successful projects throughout the City with no City funding,” and that the only one with public money was 31st Street.23  That is false.  The VBDA had paid Thompson $2.5 million for this inn, and Council had given his Cavalier $10.57 million in 2013.22, 24

The Cavalier:  Gold Key’s biggest public deal

Gold Key | PHR developed the Cavalier for Cavalier Associates, LLC.  The City put $13,019,040 into it in 2013, the City and state promised up to $24.5 million more in sales taxes, and in 2026 the buyer took over that deal.  Every vote, the money, and TowneBank’s role are in our Cavalier post.

Inside the VBDA:  Gold Key’s people on the board

  • Bryan Cuffee:  Gold Key | PHR’s vice president for development joined the VBDA in September 2011 and was its treasurer in 2017 and 2018.  Cuffee held a stake in the Cavalier through a separate LLC since at least January 1, 2017.  On February 21, 2017, the day the VBDA took up the Cavalier, Gold Key’s chief investment officer, Robert M. Howard, told the VBDA in writing that no City official had an interest in the project.3
  • Michael Levinson:  A partner in COTH, LLC, an original 2013 Cavalier investor, Levinson sat on the VBDA from 2014 to 2018, did legal work for Thompson’s hotels, and sits on the TowneBank board.3
  • Linwood Branch:  See Beach Quarters Inn, above.22

The TCC hotel:  Gold Key and MEB

After a VBDA request for qualifications, the City picked Princess Anne Hospitality, which City records describe as MEB General Contractors and Gold Key | PHR together, to build a “teaching hotel” next to Tidewater Community College.  On October 20, 2015, Council voted ‘aye’, 11-0, for a legislative agenda asking the General Assembly for $10 million for it.25

The pier:  City land for $1 a year

In 2016, Thompson was among those who first proposed a new Oceanfront pier on City land.  On March 20, 2018, the VBDA resolved to take part in the pier project with the responding developer.26  On May 15, 2018, Virginia Beach Pier Place Development, LLC, with Thompson as a partner, bid $1 a year to lease the City land.  The pier’s cost to taxpayers could reach $21.5 million.27

The money:  Gold Key’s own gifts

Gifts in the company’s name (Gold Key | PHR and PHR/GKR Holding Co.).  Thompson’s personal gifts are on our Bruce Thompson post.

  • Michael Berlucchi:  $5,000 on September 19, 2020; $3,500 on March 25, 2026, 55 days before his ‘aye’ on the Cavalier handoff.28, 29
  • Amelia Ross-Hammond:  $1,500 on May 28, 2013; $5,000 on October 26, 2016; $2,500 on February 28, 2025, 32 days before her ‘aye’ on the Cavalier beach franchise.30, 31
  • Joash Schulman:  $2,500 on November 5, 2022.32
  • Barbara Henley:  $1,000 on September 12, 2014.33
  • Ben Davenport:  $5,000 on June 9, 2014; Cuffee $250 on November 2, 2014.34
  • Shannon Kane:  $500 on February 18, 2015.35

Taken from the public:

  1. $7,937,262 to Bruce Thompson (Thirty-First Street, L.C.):  public land at 31st Street the City Assessor valued at $11,600,000, sold by the VBDA for $3,662,738, June 14, 2012.  Running total:  $7,937,262.  ↩

Total in this post:  $7,937,262.  Total owed to the public, all posts:  $43,851,464.37, plus up to $20.9 million more promised.

Notes and sources:

  1. WYDaily, September 19, 2018.  ↩
  2. City Council minutes, April 6, 2021, Item 71484, PDF pages 151–155 (City Manager’s answers to Council Member Moss).  ↩
  3. Kerry Dougherty, “Special Feature:  Connections and Conflicts,” October 11, 2018.  ↩
  4. City Council minutes, June 22, 2010, Item 60072, PDF pages 96–98.  ↩
  5. City Council minutes, March 4, 2025, Item K.1 (Dam Neck Associates, LLC), consent agenda, PDF page 51; disclosure statement in the agenda, PDF page 94.  ↩
  6. Planning Commission minutes, August 10, 2022, Item 2 (Dam Neck Associates, LLC), 10-0 with one absent.  ↩
  7. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service National Wetlands Inventory map; Va. Code § 28.2-1308(B)(3).  ↩
  8. Rosemary Wilson for City Council, Friends for Rosemary Wilson, and Elect Rosemary, Schedule A:  Thompson $1,000 on November 6, 2019; $500 on August 31, 2020; $2,500 on June 23, 2022; $5,000 on September 27, 2024 (Virginia Department of Elections reports 196260, 218109, 292450, and 415720).  ↩
  9. Virginia Business, “2026 Virginia Black Business Leaders Awards:  Bryan D. Cuffee,” February 2026.  ↩
  10. VBDA Index of Abstain Letters, entry for November 17, 2020 (Lisa Murphy, CARES Act awards).  ↩
  11. VBDA minutes, October 20, 2020 (Lisa Murphy’s conflict letter); see our Willcox & Savage post.  ↩
  12. VBDA minutes, May 12, 2026, Item 4, PDF pages 1 and 4–5.  ↩
  13. Virginia Public Access Project, Every Vote Counts VB, top donors, 2025:  Professional Hospitality Resources $25,000 on November 7, 2025, and $8,050 on December 4, 2025; Lynn-Dee Motel Inc. $20,000.  ↩
  14. Governor’s veto explanation, SB 189, 2024 Session; Virginian-Pilot, Stacy Parker, February 5, 2025.  ↩
  15. GlobeSt, “$50M hotel project clears hurdle,” April 16, 2002.  ↩
  16. “Va. Beach Cavalier developer unfazed by criticism,” Associated Press via 13NewsNow, June 24, 2013.  ↩
  17. Special warranty deed, City of Virginia Beach Development Authority to Thirty-First Street, L.C., dated June 14, 2012, Instrument No. 201200068488 (recorded June 20, 2012; re-recorded July 16, 2012 as Instrument No. 201200078663), GPINs 2428-02-7323 and 2428-02-7087, consideration $3,662,738.  ↩
  18. Mike Hixenbaugh, “Developer buys land, park by 31st Street Hilton hotel,” The Virginian-Pilot, June 23, 2012 (printed copy on the Keep Virginia Beach Above Water Facebook page).  ↩
  19. Deeds of trust from Oceanfront Investments, LLC, trustee TBVAT, LLC (TowneBank), Instrument Nos. 201500096676 (October 2, 2015), 201600014813 (February 23, 2016), 201900072953 (August 29, 2019), and 202000031294 (April 8, 2020).  ↩
  20. Alissa Skelton, “Bruce Thompson sells two hotels at the Virginia Beach Oceanfront and buys another,” The Virginian-Pilot, September 7, 2018 (printed copy on the Keep Virginia Beach Above Water Facebook page).  ↩
  21. Agreements between the City of Virginia Beach and Oceanfront Condominium Association, Inc., Cavalier Oceanfront Residences, LLC, and Oceanfront Investments, LLC (and Oceanfront South, LLC), Instrument Nos. 202103077766 (recorded September 29, 2021, PDF pages 1–2, 6–9) and 202103070621 (recorded September 1, 2021, PDF pages 1–2), $1 each.  ↩
  22. Kerry Dougherty, “Special Feature:  Good Government, Virginia Beach Style, Part II,” September 6, 2018.  ↩
  23. City Council minutes, March 7, 2017, Item 66845, PDF page 141 (the minutes’ summary of R. J. Nutter’s remarks).  ↩
  24. City Council minutes, July 2, 2013, Item 62964, PDF page 44.  ↩
  25. City Council minutes, October 20, 2015, Item 65313, PDF pages 59 and 90.  ↩
  26. VBDA Index of Abstain Letters, entry for March 20, 2018 (Entertainment District, Pier).  ↩
  27. WYDaily, May 15, 2018.  ↩
  28. Friends of Michael Berlucchi and Friends of Michael F. Berlucchi, Schedule A (reports 218649 and 494933).  ↩
  29. City Council minutes, May 19, 2026, Item K.2 (Item 78358), PDF pages 50–52.  ↩
  30. Friends of Ross-Hammond and Amelia for Virginia Beach, Schedule A (reports 134616, 102279, and 448279).  ↩
  31. City Council minutes, April 1, 2025, Item 76858, PDF page 170.  ↩
  32. Schulman for City Council, Schedule A (report 301360).  ↩
  33. Henley for Council, Schedule A (report 46335).  ↩
  34. Friends of Ben Davenport, Schedule A (reports 44192 and 48281).  ↩
  35. Friends of Shannon Kane, Schedule A (report 155015).  ↩

Last updated November 21, 2026.

Have records or evidence about this?  Email keepvbabovewater@gmail.com.

Comments

Leave a Reply