In Holloway v. City of Virginia Beach, a federal judge found the City’s at-large elections illegal under the Voting Rights Act.1 The City, Council, and the City Manager are the defendants, represented by City Attorney Mark Stiles and an outside Washington, D.C., law firm, Baker & Hostetler, paid with public funds.2 We checked what the City told a federal judge against the court’s own findings. And guess what, the judge found the City “materially misled both Plaintiffs and the Court.”3
The biggest problem: Council, after promising a federal judge it would adopt the 10-1 system, blocking that system’s charter change 7-4 under a rule it raised itself, with the four ‘nay’ votes from members funded by Bruce Thompson, who wrote Council against 10-1 before the vote.4
⚠ The law: What the record shows
- No voting system may result in “a denial or abridgement of the right … to vote on account of race or color.” 52 U.S.C. § 10301(a)
- No locality may use a voting practice that “results in, is likely to result in, or is intended to result in” abridging a protected class’s right to vote. Va. Code § 24.2-126(A)
- A change in how the City elects Council needs state preclearance first. Va. Code § 24.2-129
- An attorney “shall not knowingly make a false statement of fact or law to a tribunal.” Va. Rules of Prof’l Conduct 3.3(a)(1)
- Federal law is “the supreme Law of the Land”; a local referendum cannot approve what federal law bars. U.S. Const. art. VI, cl. 2
- The court’s finding: “Defendants have materially misled both Plaintiffs and the Court.”3
What the City said versus what the law says:
- “Irreparable harm.” In July 2021, the City asked to hold one more election under the at-large system the court had just found illegal, claiming the court’s order “would inflict irreparable harm on the City and the public.”5 FALSE. The court: “The Court disagrees with Defendants’ position and their legal analysis is, again, misguided.” A majority of Council is a quorum, so ten members can still do the people’s business. The court added that the City “has been consistently unresponsive to the economic and social needs of the Minority Community.”6
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: The City fought to run another election under a system a federal judge had found illegal, causing minority residents’ votes to be diluted again. - “No authority” after the appeal. After the Fourth Circuit ruled, the City told the judge, “This Court has no authority to stay proceedings,” and “The Fourth Circuit did not authorize this Court to … [hold] this case open.”7 FALSE. The Fourth Circuit wrote: “We follow that advice here, and remand without instructions to dismiss the plaintiffs’ case.”8 The judge ruled, “contrary to Defendants’ assertions, the Court retains subject-matter jurisdiction over this case.”9 The City never won on the merits. The appeals court vacated only because the General Assembly had already outlawed the City’s at-large system.10 Yet the day of the ruling, Deputy City Attorney Christopher Boynton told the press, “The city feels vindicated.”11 The City’s own website then told residents the Fourth Circuit ruled “that the district court erred in its decision.” The court said only that the judge “erred in reaching the merits.” The City later took the page down.12
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: The City spun a ruling on a technicality as a win to get the case thrown out, causing residents to nearly lose the court’s protection of their vote. Residents paid the outside firm nearly $1.5 million by January 2022, with the appeal alone costing more than $1 million.13 - “Futile.” The City told the judge on June 16, 2025, that it dropped the 10-1 charter request because asking would be futile, citing the Governor’s vetoes and a state lawsuit.14 FALSE. The General Assembly passed the City’s 10-1 charter change in 2024 and a 10-1 fix again in 2025.15 On November 12, 2024, seven of eleven Council members voted to ask again. It failed only because, on September 19, 2023, Council raised the bar to nine votes, 7-4, at the request of Mayor Bobby Dyer and Rosemary Wilson.16 In March 2026, the charter change passed and became law.17
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: Four members overrode seven to keep a dilutive system alive, causing years of uncertainty and more taxpayer-paid litigation. - “Nothing material has changed.” On May 12, 2025, the City told the judge, “Nothing material has changed,” and that residents “ended the suit on their own volition.”18 FALSE. The court found the residents dismissed “solely in reliance on Defendants’ explicit representations that they would implement the 10-1 election system,” and that the City’s turnaround “constitute[s] a material change in circumstances.”19
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: The City blamed residents for trusting its word, causing them to fight to get back into court. - “No future promises.” At the same hearing, the judge recorded the City’s argument “that they did not make any future promises after dismissing this case.”20 FALSE. The court: “Defendants did represent to Plaintiffs and the Court that they were ending their contest of this litigation and adopting the 10-1 system.”20 The City’s September 6, 2023, notice to the court laid out its steps, including a charter change.21 The judge found the City “materially misled both Plaintiffs and the Court” and called its conduct “an intentional effort to avoid compliance with federal law and subvert a lawful electoral remedy.”3
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: Residents’ attorneys dropped the case on the City’s word, and the City walked away from it, causing residents to have to sue all over again. - “A large number of possible ways” to make 7-3-1 work. In federal court, the City wrote that “there are a large number of possible ways to configure a 7-3-1 plan” and “it is possible that a 7-3-1 plan with three minority opportunity districts may emerge.”22 FALSE. In state court, the same City said “a 7-3-1 system could not yield three Black minority (or coalition minority) opportunity districts” and that it was unable to produce one.23 The court’s special master found 7-3-1 “can only produce two.”24 And on July 18, 2023, Boynton told Council: “The barriers to any system other than the 10-1 are strong, if not insurmountable.”25
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: The City tells each court whatever wins that day, causing residents to fund both sides of its own argument. - Let the voters decide. The City defended putting 7-3-1 back on the ballot, saying it would be “inconsistent with democratic principles, for the General Assembly to rebuff a charter change requested by the very people subject to the charter.”26 NOT ALLOWED. A local vote cannot approve a system that dilutes minority votes; federal law controls. The court: “this referendum invites the public to legitimize a system that would violate Section 2.” And the people had already spoken: the City’s own survey found 81% prefer 10-1.27
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: The City asked the majority to vote away the minority’s rights after 81% had already chosen 10-1, causing residents to pay for an election the law can’t honor. - “Not involved” in the ballot question. At the hearing, the City admitted, as the judge recorded, that the City Attorney “was not involved in drafting the language in the referendum.”28 Yet on April 1, 2025, Deputy City Attorney Christopher Boynton told Council: “We propose a neutral question to you as your attorneys, and then you decide to adopt it or not.”29 The City also conceded that “private individuals have been exerting significant influence over the City’s ability to implement electoral changes.”28
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: Private interests, not residents, steer how residents elect their Council.
What the City told a second federal judge in 2026:
In the VB National lawsuit, the City’s attorneys at Willcox & Savage retold Holloway to a different judge.30
- “Reversed by the Fourth Circuit.” The City wrote: “The Court initially held that the voting districting was illegal, but that decision was reversed by the Fourth Circuit.”31 FALSE. Nothing was reversed. The Fourth Circuit vacated the ruling as moot because the General Assembly had already ended at-large voting, never reached whether the system was legal, and sent the case back “without instructions to dismiss.”810
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: The City rewrites a ruling that its election system was illegal into a win, so residents are told the system was cleared when it never was. - “Neither the City nor its City Attorney’s Office misled the Court.”32 FALSE. Judge Jackson found: “Defendants have materially misled both Plaintiffs and the Court.”3
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: The City denies a federal court’s finding against it, so the officials responsible face no consequences. - “The City was true to its word.”31 FALSE. After promising the court a charter change, Council raised the vote needed to request one, then let the request fail 7-4 under the new bar, then put 7-3-1 back on the ballot.1633
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: Residents relied on the City’s word and had to go back to court to hold it to that word. - “It has been implemented. No one’s hurt now.” City attorney Gary Bryant told the judge the City had implemented “the program that the federal court directed the City to implement,” and “No one’s hurt now as a result of what’s happening in Holloway.”34 FALSE. The City did not deliver 10-1. Voters chose it in the November 4, 2025 referendum, and the General Assembly and Governor Spanberger put it in the charter in 2026, after Council’s majority had tried to bring back 7-3-1.3536
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: The City takes credit for a fix residents won over its opposition, and residents paid for both sides of the fight.
Who voted with the donor:
Before the November 12, 2024, vote, Bruce Thompson wrote Council backing 7-3-1, opposing 10-1, and asking for an Attorney General opinion or a referendum.37 The four ‘nay’ votes: Dyer ($15,000 from Thompson), Wilson ($9,000), Berlucchi ($16,000), and Henley ($1,000).33 Dyer asked Attorney General Jason Miyares for the opinion, as Thompson wanted. Thompson gave Miyares $25,000 on December 30, 2024. Miyares’s letter calling 7-3-1 lawful followed on January 30, 2025.38
Thompson gives Miyares $25,000
Miyares letter calls 7-3-1 lawful
On May 6, 2025, Council voted 7-4 to put 7-3-1 on the ballot. ‘Aye’: Dyer, Wilson, Berlucchi, Henley, Ross-Hammond ($10,000 from Thompson), Cummings ($1,500), and Jackson-Green ($9,000). ‘Nay’: Remick, Hutcheson, Schulman, and Rouse.39 Cummings then gave $10,000 to the committee pushing 7-3-1.40
The City’s own record:
- March 31, 2021: The court finds the at-large system illegal.1
- July 19, 2021: The court denies the City’s bid to hold one more at-large election.6
- July 27, 2022: The Fourth Circuit vacates as moot and sends the case back “without instructions to dismiss.”8
- November 15, 2022: The court rejects the City’s claim it has no jurisdiction.9
- August 15, 2023: Council adopts 10-1 by ordinance; the City’s survey shows 81% support.21
- September 6, 2023: The City tells the court its steps, including a charter change.21
- September 19, 2023: Council raises the charter-request bar to nine votes, 7-4.16
- November 27, 2023: Residents’ attorneys dismiss the case, relying on the City’s word.3
- November 12, 2024: The 10-1 charter request fails 7-4 under the new bar.4
- May 6, 2025: Council votes 7-4 to put 7-3-1 on the ballot.39
- May 12, 2025: The City tells the judge “Nothing material has changed.”18
- July 8, 2025: The court reopens the case, finding the City “materially misled” it.3
- March 2026: The 10-1 charter change becomes law.17
- April 14, 2026: With 10-1 in the charter and the state lawsuit dismissed, residents’ attorneys dismiss the case.36
The City is supposed to represent the public. In Holloway, it told a federal judge one thing and did another.
Related: Bruce Thompson; Owed to the public.
Report it:
- Attorney misconduct: Virginia State Bar Intake Office, 1111 East Main Street, Suite 700, Richmond, VA 23219-0026; (804) 775-0570, or 1-866-548-0873 outside the 804 area code; webintake@vsb.org. VSB complaint form
- Voting rights violations: U.S. Department of Justice, Civil Rights Division. civilrights.justice.gov
Notes and sources:
- Holloway v. City of Virginia Beach, No. 2:18-cv-00069 (E.D. Va.), Memorandum Opinion and Order (March 31, 2021), reported at 531 F. Supp. 3d 1015. Page numbers below are the court’s stamped page numbers. ↩
- Defendants’ Consolidated Brief in Support of Motion to Dismiss and in Opposition to Motion to Stay (October 18, 2022), page 6, signature block: Mark D. Stiles, City Attorney; Christopher S. Boynton, Deputy City Attorney; Gerald L. Harris, Senior City Attorney; Joseph M. Kurt, Assistant City Attorney; Katherine L. McKnight, Richard B. Raile, Patrick T. Lewis, and Erika Dackin Prouty, Baker & Hostetler, LLP, “Counsel for Defendants.” ↩
- Memorandum Opinion and Order (July 8, 2025), page 13 (“materially misled”), page 11 (“an intentional effort to avoid compliance with federal law and subvert a lawful electoral remedy”), and pages 3 and 8 (dismissal on November 27, 2023, “in reliance on Defendants’ representations”). ↩
- Plaintiffs’ Second Amended Complaint (August 7, 2025), pages 31–32, ¶¶ 154–158 (allegations). ↩
- Memorandum Opinion and Order (July 19, 2021), pages 11–12, quoting Defendants’ Emergency Motion to Stay Injunction. ↩
- Memorandum Opinion and Order (July 19, 2021), page 12 (“again, misguided”), page 14 (quorum, City Charter § 3.06), and page 15 (“consistently unresponsive”). ↩
- Defendants’ Consolidated Brief in Support of Motion to Dismiss and in Opposition to Motion to Stay (October 18, 2022), pages 1 and 5. ↩
- Holloway v. City of Virginia Beach, 42 F.4th 266 (4th Cir. 2022), slip opinion (July 27, 2022), page 20. ↩
- Order (November 15, 2022), page 3. ↩
- Holloway, 42 F.4th 266, slip opinion, page 4 (the General Assembly’s law left “an electoral system that no longer governs elections in Virginia Beach. It follows that this case is moot”). ↩
- Stacy Parker, “Virginia Beach wins appeal of voting district lawsuit, but ward system will stick for now,” The Virginian-Pilot, July 27, 2022. ↩
- City of Virginia Beach, “Holloway vs. City of Virginia Beach,” Communications Office web page, “Outcome of the Appeal,” as archived by the Internet Archive on October 20, 2022; the page returned “not found” by November 25, 2024. Fourth Circuit language: Holloway, 42 F.4th 266, slip opinion, page 4. ↩
- Stacy Parker, “Virginia Beach taxpayers on hook for legal costs as city appeals voting rights lawsuit,” The Virginian-Pilot, January 12, 2022 (“nearly $1.5 million, and it’s not over yet”); Parker, The Virginian-Pilot, July 27, 2022 (appeal “at a cost of more than $1 million”). WHRO reported on January 24, 2022, that Council voted 6-4 to continue the appeal, risking $3.6 million in the residents’ attorney fees after they offered to settle for $1.6 million. ↩
- Memorandum Opinion and Order (July 8, 2025), pages 5 and 10. ↩
- Plaintiffs’ Second Amended Complaint (August 7, 2025), pages 30–31 and 36, ¶¶ 145–152 (SB189 passed and vetoed May 17, 2024) and ¶¶ 175–177 (HB1990 passed February 2025, vetoed March 24, 2025). ↩
- Plaintiffs’ Second Amended Complaint (August 7, 2025), pages 28–29 and 32, ¶¶ 140–142, 155–158. ↩
- Campaign Legal Center, Holloway, et al. v. City of Virginia Beach case page (updated March 9, 2026). ↩
- Defendants’ Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Rule 60(b) Motion for Relief from Judgment (May 12, 2025), page 1. ↩
- Memorandum Opinion and Order (July 8, 2025), page 13. ↩
- Memorandum Opinion and Order (July 8, 2025), page 5. ↩
- Defendants’ Notice of City Council Action on Redistricting (September 6, 2023), as described in Memorandum Opinion and Order (July 8, 2025), pages 3 and 10, and Plaintiffs’ Second Amended Complaint (August 7, 2025), pages 27–28, ¶¶ 133–139. ↩
- Defendants’ Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Rule 60(b) Motion for Relief from Judgment (May 12, 2025), page 6. ↩
- City’s brief in Branch v. City of Virginia Beach, No. CL24-322 (Va. Beach Cir. Ct.), pages 4 and 27, as quoted in Plaintiffs’ Second Amended Complaint (August 7, 2025), page 42, ¶¶ 203–204. ↩
- Memorandum Opinion and Order (July 8, 2025), page 2, note 1, and page 8, citing the Special Master’s Report. ↩
- Stacy Parker, “Virginia Beach must take action on ward-based election system or risk lawsuit, city attorney warns,” The Virginian-Pilot, July 19, 2023 (City Council informal session, July 18, 2023). ↩
- Defendants’ Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Rule 60(b) Motion for Relief from Judgment (May 12, 2025), page 9. ↩
- Memorandum Opinion and Order (July 8, 2025), pages 10–11 (City survey, 81%; “invites the public to legitimize”). ↩
- Memorandum Opinion and Order (July 8, 2025), page 11. ↩
- City Council briefing, April 1, 2025, as quoted in Plaintiffs’ Second Amended Complaint (August 7, 2025), page 37, ¶ 181. ↩
- SFF Conservation Initiative, Inc., et al. v. City of Virginia Beach, et al., No. 2:26-cv-00738 (E.D. Va.); see our post VB National. ↩
- City Defendants’ Memorandum in Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Motion to Disqualify (August 25, 2026), page 12, SFF Conservation Initiative case. ↩
- City Defendants’ Memorandum in Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Motion to Disqualify (August 25, 2026), page 13, SFF Conservation Initiative case. The City’s Memorandum in Support of Motion to Dismiss (August 20, 2026), page 43, adds that the City “is now in full compliance with the election plan approved by the presiding judge in Holloway.” ↩
- Virginia Department of Elections campaign finance reports, totals for Thompson and his companies as compiled on our Bruce Thompson post. ↩
- Transcript of Motions Hearing, October 16, 2026, page 78, SFF Conservation Initiative case. ↩
- Order (November 7, 2025), page 2 (“The citizens of Virginia Beach voted to adopt a 10-1 electoral system”); Transcript of Motions Hearing, October 16, 2026, pages 104–105, SFF Conservation Initiative case (charter change “signed into law by Governor Spanberger”). ↩
- Stipulation of Dismissal (April 14, 2026), page 1 (“In light of the enactment of Senate Bills 681 and 51 … and the dismissal of the Branch et al. v. City of Virginia Beach, et al. state litigation”). ↩
- Plaintiffs’ Second Amended Complaint (August 7, 2025), page 31, ¶ 154. ↩
- Plaintiffs’ Second Amended Complaint (August 7, 2025), page 32, note 6 (Miyares letter to Dyer, January 30, 2025; Thompson $25,000 to Miyares, December 30, 2024). ↩
- Plaintiffs’ Second Amended Complaint (August 7, 2025), page 41, ¶¶ 197–198; Thompson totals as in note 33. ↩
- Plaintiffs’ Second Amended Complaint (August 7, 2025), page 39, ¶ 189 (Every Vote Counts). ↩
Last updated November 22, 2026.
Have records or evidence about this? Email keepvbabovewater@gmail.com.

Leave a Reply