The City of Virginia Beach, the VBDA, and Dragas are defendants in a federal lawsuit over the VB National site.1 The City’s lawyers at Willcox & Savage represent the City, Mayor Bobby Dyer, Rosemary Wilson, Patrick Duhaney, and Mark Stiles.2 We checked defendants’ filings and what they told a federal judge against the law. And guess what, more misstatements of law that are meant to harm residents so developers profit.
⚠ The law: What the record shows
- All of Virginia Beach is “Tidewater Virginia,” and every Tidewater city “shall” designate Bay Act areas. Va. Code §§ 62.1-44.15:68, :74(A)
- Bay Act areas are set by wetlands, tidal shores, and buffers, not by where water drains. 9VAC25-830-80(B)
- Since October 1, 2001, filling, draining, or flooding any wetland in Virginia takes a state permit; state law covers all wetlands, not just those tied to the Bay. Va. Code §§ 62.1-44.3, 62.1-44.15:20(A)(2)
- In Bay Act areas, stormwater rules start at 2,500 square feet. Va. Code § 62.1-44.15:34(E)(3)
- The City “shall update the MS4 Program Plan annually.” MS4 Permit Part I.A.6
- Staffing “shall not be an acceptable explanation” for missing permit duties. MS4 Permit Part I.A
- The City must keep “an accurate MS4 map.” MS4 Permit Part I.B.2.h
- The City must “effectively prohibit” non-stormwater discharges, not just report them. 33 U.S.C. § 1342(p)(3)(B)(ii)
What the City said versus what the law says:
- “Never reaches the Chesapeake Bay.” The City says its Bay Act area “does not include property if stormwater runoff on the property never reaches the Chesapeake Bay.”3 FALSE. State law names Virginia Beach, with no watershed carve-out.4 The same brief admits “All localities within ‘Tidewater Virginia’ are statutorily required to comply with the CBPA.”5
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: The City drops Bay Act protection for half the City so builders can fill wetlands, causing flooding for residents. - “Authorizes localities.” The City told the court the Bay Act “authorizes localities” to create Bay Act areas.6 FALSE. The law says “shall,” twice.4
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: The City makes a legal duty to residents sound optional so builders can skip Bay Act rules, causing runoff and flooding for residents. - Sworn: “only within the Chesapeake Bay watershed.” City engineer Melanie Coffey swore “The State requires a 2,500 sq. ft. threshold only within the Chesapeake Bay watershed.”7 FALSE. The statute ties 2,500 to Bay Act designation, which the City is required to make.8 The City’s own annual report says the state’s 10,000 figure is for land “outside of the Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area,” not outside a watershed.9
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: Builders skip stormwater controls on projects up to 10,000 square feet, causing runoff onto neighbors. - “DEQ would have noted the violation.” FALSE. It did. In June 2007, the state found the City “noncompliant” with its own Bay ordinance.10
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: The City hides the state’s finding so builders keep getting approvals under the same rules, causing the damage to go unfixed for residents. - “Nothing more than submitting a permit annually.” That is how the City described its duty to update its stormwater plan.11 FALSE. The permit says the City “shall update the MS4 Program Plan annually.” Nobody submits a permit annually; the state issued it once, for five years.12
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: The City treats its yearly runoff plan as paperwork so building goes on unchecked, causing polluted runoff into residents’ waterways. - Staffing. Coffey swore the City “did not meet the required BMP inspections” and blamed “staffing vacancies.”13 NOT ALLOWED. The permit says staffing “shall not be an acceptable explanation.”14 At the hearing, Bryant called missed inspections “administrative matters. We do the best we can.”15
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: Builders’ stormwater ponds go uninspected, causing failures that flood residents’ homes. - “No legal obligation to survey.” City lawyer Gary Bryant told the judge, “We know of no legal obligation to survey and control receiving drainage.”16 FALSE. The permit requires “an accurate MS4 map,” outfalls included.17
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: The City won’t map its drainage so builders can tie into a system no one tracks, causing flooding residents can’t get fixed. - “Report and address.” The City says it only has to “discover and report releases and address those releases.”18 FALSE. Federal law and the permit say “effectively prohibit.”19
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: Builders’ pollution reaches the water before anyone stops it, causing residents to pay for the cleanup. - Sworn: “The City met these requirements.” Coffey swore the City is “in compliance with its MS4 permit” and met its duty to report progress on pollution limits to the state. The City’s brief said “it is not true that the City is in violation of its MS4 Permit.”20 FALSE. At the hearing, Bryant admitted the phosphorus numbers were not in the City’s annual report, “and so those numbers didn’t go to the State,” and conceded “it’s a Clean Water Act violation.”21
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: The City tells a judge it is in compliance while the state never gets the pollution numbers, causing more phosphorus in residents’ rivers. - “Confidentiality is necessary to protect developers.” The City defended its secret talks and nondisclosure agreement with Dragas by claiming “the General Assembly has recognized that confidentiality is necessary to protect developers and other businesses looking to invest in public projects in Virginia.”22 FALSE. The law says records and meetings “shall be presumed open,” and every exemption “shall be narrowly construed.”23
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: The City keeps a public land deal secret to protect a developer, causing residents to lose their chance to object. - “FOIA requires that we do it that way.” On Mayor Dyer setting up a developer meeting with just one official, Bryant told the judge: “It’s because FOIA requires that we do it that way.” He added, “it is routine that one or perhaps two City officials will sit down with the developer.”24 FALSE. FOIA requires no private meetings. It requires public notice once three members meet, and it presumes every meeting open.25
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: Developers get private time with the Mayor that stays under the notice line, causing residents to learn of deals only after they are set. - “No City official has a personal, financial stake.” The City told the court no City official has a stake in the project or in Dragas, “all of which was and is true.”26 At the hearing, Bryant said no official “received anything.”27 Council voted 9-2 to hand VB National to Dragas. The aye voters had taken Dragas campaign money: Dyer ($20,000), Wilson ($16,000), Berlucchi ($9,750), Ross-Hammond ($8,750), Cummings ($3,000), Jackson-Green ($3,000), and Schulman ($3,000).28
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: Public land goes to a donor by the votes of officials who took that donor’s money. - Taxpayers pay their attorneys. The City called it “frivolous” to make the officials pay their own defense costs.29 The law says the City “may” hire counsel, and only for actions “in furtherance of their duties in serving the locality.”30 So taxpayers pay Willcox & Savage, whose partner Lisa Murphy chairs the VBDA, a co-defendant.31
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: Residents pay the lawyers defending the handoff of public land to a developer. - “A program efficiency.” On 12 sewage spills in one year, Bryant said: “We would submit that it represents a program efficiency.”32
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: The City calls sewage spills a success instead of fixing them, causing residents to live with the sewage. - “No one’s hurt now” by Holloway. Bryant told the judge the City was slow to carry out the voting-rights remedy the federal court ordered in Holloway v. City of Virginia Beach, and “No one’s hurt now as a result of what’s happening in Holloway.”33 The Holloway court found the City’s conduct “reflects not a mere lapse in execution but an intentional effort to avoid compliance with federal law,” and that “Defendants have materially misled both Plaintiffs and the Court.”34
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: Residents wait years for the voting districts a federal court ordered, causing their votes to count less. - Dragas: nothing is happening until 2027. On August 18, 2026, Dragas told the court it “has neither acquired the property nor begun any work on it.”35 FALSE. Three days later, Helen Dragas swore her firms “have already commenced on-site due diligence and environmental and civil engineering work, committing more than $800,000 to that work alone.”36 On September 1, 2026, Dragas filed to rezone 52.357 acres of VB National for more than 650 condominiums, “Princess Anne Landing,” plus 1.8 acres for a child care center.37 Both are expected before the Planning Commission on December 9, 2026.38 Yet on November 2, 2026, Dragas told the court again that it “has not acquired the property or begun any work on it, and whose approvals are not due until June 30, 2027.”39 The VBDA and the City leaned on the same 2027 date.40
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: Dragas moves more than 650 condominiums on public land toward a vote while telling the court there is no hurry, causing residents to run out of time. - “Vote them out.” The City’s lawyers wrote: “If Plaintiffs do not like the decisions of the elected officials, they can vote them out. But the problem is that Plaintiffs are in a minority.”41
HOW THIS HURTS RESIDENTS: The City’s lawyers tell residents who ask for the law to be enforced that they don’t count.
The City’s own record:
- November 6, 1990: Council adopts the Bay ordinance; Tuck Bowie speaks for the Tidewater Builders Association.42
- March 10, 1992: Planning Director Robert J. Scott tells Council the southern half of the City gets its own, separate ordinance.43
- October 1, 2001: State law makes it unlawful to fill, drain, or flood any wetland without a state permit. Va. Code § 62.1-44.15:20(A)(2)
- June 2007: The state finds the City “noncompliant” with its Bay ordinance.10
- April 28, 2009: Council calls the same ordinance “one of the most successful Chesapeake Bay Ordinances in the State,” 10-1, with only Wood voting nay.10
- September 17, 2024: Council treats land disturbance outside Bay Act areas differently from inside them, 11-0.44
- August 19, 2025: Council limits the Bay ordinance to “lands which are included in the Chesapeake Bay watershed,” 11-0.45
- August 18 to 21, 2026: Dragas says no work has begun; Helen Dragas swears to more than $800,000 of work.35, 36
- September 1, 2026: Dragas files the Princess Anne Landing rezoning.37
- November 2, 2026: Dragas tells the court again it has not “begun any work.”39
- December 9, 2026: Planning Commission hearing expected on the Dragas rezonings.38
Tidewater should be the strictest in the state. The law says so.4 The City told a federal judge the opposite.
Related: Dragas in Chesapeake; Owed to the public.
Report it to the state:
The Virginia Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ) enforces the Bay Act, the state stormwater law, and the City’s MS4 permit.
- DEQ Tidewater Regional Office: 5636 Southern Boulevard, Virginia Beach, VA 23462; (757) 518-2000.
- Bay Act program: ask for DEQ’s Chesapeake Bay Preservation Act liaison for Virginia Beach, who handles citizen complaints and the City’s compliance review. DEQ local program compliance
- Spills, discharges, or land disturbance without controls: (757) 518-2077, or file online. DEQ pollution reporting
- Statewide: (804) 698-4000, or 1-800-592-5482 toll-free in Virginia.
Notes and sources:
- SFF Conservation Initiative, Inc., et al. v. City of Virginia Beach, et al., No. 2:26-cv-00738 (E.D. Va.). Page numbers below are the court’s stamped page numbers. ↩
- City Defendants’ Memorandum in Support of Motion to Dismiss (August 20, 2026), signature block: Gary A. Bryant, Brett A. Spain, and Bethany J. Fogerty, Willcox & Savage, P.C., “Counsel for City of Virginia Beach, Robert M. Dyer, Rosemary A. Wilson, Patrick A. Duhaney and Mark D. Stiles.” ↩
- City Defendants’ Memorandum in Support of Motion to Dismiss (August 20, 2026), page 40. The next sentence: “This is true for all property in the Southern Rivers Watershed.” Page 39: “There is no authority, however, requiring a municipality to apply those criteria to any property outside of the Chesapeake Bay Watershed.” Same claim in City Defendants’ Memorandum in Opposition to Motion for Preliminary Injunction (August 10, 2026), page 10, adding the Atlantic Ocean. ↩
- Va. Code § 62.1-44.15:68 (“Tidewater Virginia” includes the City of “Virginia Beach”); Va. Code § 62.1-44.15:74(A) (Tidewater localities “shall use the criteria developed by the Board,” and designation “shall be accomplished by every county, city, and town in Tidewater Virginia”). ↩
- City Defendants’ Memorandum in Support of Motion to Dismiss (August 20, 2026), page 37. ↩
- City Defendants’ Memorandum in Opposition to Motion for Preliminary Injunction (August 10, 2026), page 23. ↩
- Declaration of Melanie Coffey, Professional Engineer, Public Works, MS4 Permit Administrator (August 10, 2026), page 5, ¶ 17; see also page 2, ¶ 4. ↩
- Va. Code § 62.1-44.15:34(E)(3) (“in an area designated as a Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area,” criteria apply to activity that “disturbs 2,500 square feet or more of land”); 9VAC25-830-80(B). ↩
- City MS4 Permit Annual Report, Exhibit 2 to City Defendants’ Memorandum in Support of Motion to Dismiss, page 11. ↩
- City Council minutes, April 28, 2009, Item 58764, PDF pages 104–110 (staff background, PDF page 109: “In June 2007, CBLAB found the City of Virginia Beach noncompliant with its implementation of the Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area (CBPA) Ordinance”). Moved by Jones, seconded by Dyer. The “DEQ would have noted the violation” quote is in City Defendants’ Memorandum in Opposition to Motion for Preliminary Injunction (August 10, 2026), page 23. ↩
- City Defendants’ Memorandum in Support of Motion to Dismiss (August 20, 2026), page 33. ↩
- City MS4 Permit No. VA0088676, Exhibit 1 to City Defendants’ Memorandum in Support of Motion to Dismiss, page 5 (Part I.A.6) and page 1 (effective January 26, 2024, to January 25, 2029). ↩
- Declaration of Melanie Coffey (August 10, 2026), page 4, ¶ 12. ↩
- City MS4 Permit No. VA0088676, page 4. ↩
- Transcript of Motions Hearing, October 16, 2026, page 78. ↩
- Transcript of Motions Hearing, October 16, 2026, page 77. Same claim in City Defendants’ Response to the Court’s Order Regarding Plaintiffs’ Notice of Correction (November 2, 2026), page 24. ↩
- City MS4 Permit No. VA0088676, page 13 (Part I.B.2.h)3)). ↩
- City Defendants’ Memorandum in Opposition to Motion for Leave to Amend (October 7, 2026), page 17; City Defendants’ Memorandum in Opposition to Motion for Preliminary Injunction (August 10, 2026), page 24. ↩
- 33 U.S.C. § 1342(p)(3)(B)(ii); City MS4 Permit No. VA0088676, page 10 (Part I.B.2.e: “Discharges to the MS4 not authorized by this state permit shall be effectively prohibited”). ↩
- Declaration of Melanie Coffey (August 10, 2026), page 2, ¶ 6; City Defendants’ Memorandum in Support of Motion to Dismiss (August 20, 2026), page 34. ↩
- Transcript of Motions Hearing, October 16, 2026, pages 72–73. ↩
- City Defendants’ Memorandum in Support of Motion to Dismiss (August 20, 2026), page 19; same argument in City Defendants’ Memorandum in Opposition to Motion for Preliminary Injunction (August 10, 2026), page 16. ↩
- Va. Code § 2.2-3700(B). ↩
- Transcript of Motions Hearing, October 16, 2026, page 62. ↩
- Va. Code § 2.2-3701 (a “meeting” includes an informal assemblage of “as many as three members” of a public body); Va. Code § 2.2-3700(B) (meetings “shall be presumed open”). ↩
- City Defendants’ Memorandum in Opposition to Motion for Preliminary Injunction (August 10, 2026), page 20; City Defendants’ Memorandum in Support of Motion to Dismiss (August 20, 2026), page 21. The statement describes Dragas’s “Anti-collusion Form.” ↩
- Transcript of Motions Hearing, October 16, 2026, page 64. ↩
- City Council minutes, August 11, 2026, Item K.1 (9-2, Henley and Remick nay); Virginia Department of Elections campaign finance reports, totals as compiled on our Dragas post. ↩
- City Defendants’ Memorandum in Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Motion to Disqualify (August 25, 2026), page 14. ↩
- Va. Code § 15.2-1520. ↩
- City Defendants’ Memorandum in Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Motion to Disqualify (August 25, 2026), pages 7 and 10–11. ↩
- Transcript of Motions Hearing, October 16, 2026, page 77. ↩
- Transcript of Motions Hearing, October 16, 2026, page 78. ↩
- Holloway v. City of Virginia Beach, No. 2:18-cv-00069 (E.D. Va.), Memorandum Opinion and Order (July 8, 2025), pages 11 and 13. ↩
- Brief in Support of Dragas Associates, Inc.’s Motion to Dismiss (August 18, 2026), page 11. ↩
- Declaration of Helen E. Dragas (August 21, 2026), page 4, ¶ 11. ↩
- City permit system (Accela), records 2026-PCCC-00167 (Dragas Associates, Inc. – Princess Anne Landing, applicant Helen E. Dragas, representative R. Edward Bourdon, Jr.) and 2026-PCCC-00163 (2500 Tournament Drive child care and educational facility), owner City of Virginia Beach, both “In Review,” read November 16, 2026; filing date from the City’s planning applications map layer. ↩
- City of Virginia Beach, Planning Commission 2026 Application Schedule (applications filed by October 1, 2026, go to the December 9, 2026, hearing). The December 9 agenda had not been posted as of November 22, 2026. ↩
- Defendant Dragas Associates, Inc.’s Response to Plaintiffs’ Notice of Corrections to the Proposed First Amended Complaint (November 2, 2026), pages 8–9. ↩
- VBDA’s Memorandum in Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Motion for Leave to Amend (October 7, 2026), page 5 (“the Term Sheet’s approvals are not due until June 30, 2027”); City Defendants’ Memorandum in Opposition to Motion for Leave to Amend (October 7, 2026), page 19 (“nine months away”); City Defendants’ Memorandum in Opposition to Motion for Preliminary Injunction (August 10, 2026), page 9 (“almost a year from now”). ↩
- City Defendants’ Memorandum in Opposition to Motion for Leave to Amend (October 7, 2026), page 14. ↩
- City Council minutes, November 6, 1990, Item 33674. ↩
- City Council minutes, March 10, 1992, Item 35419, PDF page 13: “Only that area that drains into the Chesapeake Bay was the subject of the Chesapeake Bay Preservation Act.” ↩
- City Council minutes, September 17, 2024, Item 76153, PDF page 128 (Appendix D, § 2.2.A). Moved by Wilson, seconded by Ross-Hammond. ↩
- City Council minutes, August 19, 2025, Item 77445, PDF page 181 (Appendix F, § 104(A)). Moved by Wilson, seconded by Berlucchi. ↩
Last updated November 22, 2026.
Have records or evidence about this? Email keepvbabovewater@gmail.com.

Leave a Reply