Ashville Park:  Builders Profited, Residents Paid

Ashville Park: the Bourdon family sold the farm for $2,448,303.50, HomeFed sold lots for $12,800,000, new homes sold for $60,148,017; after the homes flooded, Council voted 9-0 for the City to pay $11,122,796 and the developer $0

Ashville Park is where it starts.  In 2004, City Council rezoned farmland on very poorly drained soil in Princess Anne for 490 homes.1  The landowners sold, the developers sold lots, and the builders sold homes.  When the homes flooded, the City paid 100 percent of the $11,122,796 drainage fix, and the developer paid nothing.A2

Ashville Park’s biggest conflict:  Eddie Bourdon signed the 2003 rezoning as an owner of his family’s land, wrote the 2004 deeds that sold it, and came back in 2018 as the developer’s attorney when the taxpayers paid for the drainage.3, 4, 5

Who made money

  • The Bourdon family:  $2,448,303.50 for 116.5 acres of the family farm, about $21,000 an acre, on September 1, 2004.  Eddie’s mother sold 56.47 acres for $1,187,474, and his law partner Howard R. Sykes, Jr., as trustee under Eddie’s grandfather Stephen Paul Brown’s will, sold the other 60.04 acres for $1,260,829.50.  Eddie prepared both deeds.4  The family still holds about 127 acres zoned R-20 on London Bridge Road through Paul S. Brown Family, L.L.C., with Eddie as registered agent; part of it is a stretch of London Bridge Road that Council closed on February 22, 2005.  Eddie also co-owns 1936 London Bridge Road.6, 7
  • Sandler at Ashville Park, L.L.C.:  bought the land in late 2004 with a $20,359,305 loan, won Council’s approval for 499 homes in 2005, and lost the property to Wells Fargo’s ATC Realty Sixteen in 2010 “due to failure of Sandler at Ashville Park to meet loan obligations.”8, 9
  • HomeFed Corporation (HOFD Ashville Park, LLC):  bought the 450-acre community in February 2012 “for cash consideration of $17,350,000,” with 451 lots already approved.  In 2012 it sold 54 lots “for net cash consideration of $8,200,000,” and in January 2013 it sold 46 more “for net cash proceeds of $4,600,000.”  By 2015, every lot in the two villages that later flooded was sold.10, 11
  • The builders, again:  After the City paid for the drainage, HomeFed built out Grandview Village (Village C) on 116 lots, with L.M. Sandler & Sons, Inc. staff on the site plans.  From March 31, 2023 to August 7, 2026, 52 homes there sold for $60,148,017, from $928,305 to $1,560,000 each.12

The land:  Farm ditches and very poorly drained soil

Of the 313 home lots in the two villages that flooded, 192 sit on Hyde soil, which the U.S. Department of Agriculture classifies as “very poorly drained.”  The rest are mostly Acredale and Nimmo soils.13  The farm drained through ditches, and the 2018 fix had to regrade the “Historic Farm Ditch” and stabilize the “Princess Anne Farm Ditch.”14  The City later had to build a sluice gate and weir to keep tides from Back Bay and Ashville Bridge Creek out of the neighborhood’s ponds.15

By 2018, Council’s own ordinance said “the Ashville Park neighborhood has experienced repeated flooding during rain events.”2  Even after the fix, the City promised only “no flooding in any living spaces in a 100-year storm.”  Water “would still pond in yards and streets.”14

Every one of those lots is in FEMA zone X, outside the mapped flood zone, so no buyer was required to carry flood insurance.13

Timeline

  • September 5, 2003:  Eddie, his mother Betty B. Bourdon, and his brother Paul S. Bourdon sign the Ashville Park, L.L.C. rezoning proffers as owners.  Eddie signs personally on September 23, 2003.3
  • January 11, 2004:  Eddie’s uncle Claude Paul Brown dies and leaves all his real property to Eddie and Paul.6
  • February 24, 2004:  Council approves the rezoning for 490 homes, 9-1.  Mayor Meyera Oberndorf votes ‘nay’.  Voting ‘aye’:  Margaret Eure, Louis Jones, Reba McClanan, Richard Maddox, Jim Reeve, Peter Schmidt, Ron Villanueva, Rosemary Wilson, and Jim Wood.1
  • September 1, 2004:  The Bourdon family land sells to Sandler at Ashville Park, L.L.C. for $2,448,303.50, on deeds Eddie prepared.4
  • May 10, 2005:  Council approves Sandler’s changes for 499 homes, 9-2.  Reba McClanan and Mayor Oberndorf vote ‘nay’.  Bobby Dyer, Rosemary Wilson, and Jim Wood vote ‘aye’.16
  • 2010:  Wells Fargo’s ATC Realty Sixteen forecloses on Sandler.9
  • February 2012:  HomeFed buys Ashville Park for $17,350,000.10
  • 2014 and 2016:  Storms flood the neighborhood.  HomeFed tells its shareholders that “large portions of the City’s storm water management system did not perform as expected.”17  After Hurricane Matthew, water stands about three feet deep.18
  • April 16, 2018:  Diane Horsley, chairman of the Agriculture Advisory Commission and wife of Don Horsley, signs the commission’s letter agreeing to move “$1.5M (one-time) to CIP for Ashville Park” out of the farmland preservation fund.19
  • April 27, 2018:  Deputy City Manager Thomas Leahy recommends the deal:  “This is a win for the City, a win for the Developer, and most importantly, a win for the Ashville Park residents.”20
  • May 15, 2018:  Council votes 9-0 to use the farmland preservation fund for Ashville Park drainage.  Jim Wood moves, John Moss seconds.21
  • July 3, 2018:  Council passes over staff’s 72/28 split and adopts Mayor Louis Jones’s “CPA Proposal 3, Alternative Version”:  the City pays 100 percent of $11,122,796, including $7,247,000 of work assigned to the developer.  HOFD pays $0, gets 116 lots in Village C instead of 98, and hands over land for a stormwater pond and Village D.  Barbara Henley moves, Bobby Dyer seconds, and it passes 9-0.2, 22
  • July 3, 2018:  Eddie speaks for HOFD on its proffer changes that same night.23
  • August 7, 2018:  Council moves $1,000,000 from Eastern Shore Drive drainage to Ashville Park, 9-0.  Jim Wood moves, John Uhrin seconds.24  Council approves HOFD’s new proffers by consent, 9-0, on an agreement Eddie prepared.  One new proffer allows work in jurisdictional wetlands “as permitted.”5, 25
  • October 9, 2018:  The full fix for Ashville Park’s drainage is reported at $35 million.26
  • April 22, 2019:  After Sandbridge floods, Leahy says, “This weather event does not show that Ashville Park and the homes there had any effects on the flooding we saw.”27
  • Fall 2020:  The City replants trees on seven acres of Village D, the land HOFD gave away.28

Who voted to make residents pay

On July 3, 2018, all nine members present voted ‘aye’:  Ben Davenport, Bobby Dyer, Barbara Henley, Mayor Louis Jones, Shannon Kane, John Moss, John Uhrin, Rosemary Wilson, and Jim Wood.2  Dyer is now Mayor, and Henley and Wilson still sit on Council.  Wilson also voted ‘aye’ on the 2004 rezoning, and Dyer and Wilson voted ‘aye’ on Sandler’s 2005 plan.1, 16

Staff’s own first offer had the developer paying $3,114,383, or 28 percent.  Council chose the option where the developer paid nothing.14, 22

Taken from the public:

  1. $11,122,796 in drainage costs to HomeFed Corporation (president Christian Foulger).  Residents paid, builder profited:  the City pays 100 percent of Ashville Park Drainage Improvements Phase I, including $7,247,000 of on-site work assigned to HOFD Ashville Park, LLC; HOFD pays $0.  Funded in part by $1,500,000 from the farmland preservation fund and $1,000,000 moved from Eastern Shore Drive drainage.  City Council minutes, July 3, 2018, Item 68265, PDF pages 43–46; May 15, 2018, Item 68113, PDF pages 136–137; August 7, 2018, Item 68355, PDF pages 169–170.  Ledger PM-0022.  Running total:  $11,122,796.  ↩

Total in this post:  $11,122,796, residents paid, builder profited.

Notes and sources:

  1. City Council Summary of Council Actions, February 24, 2004, Item L.4 (Ashville Park:  closure of part of Flanagan’s Lane, subdivision variance, and change of zoning from AG-1/AG-2 to Conditional PD-H2 R-30 and P-1), PDF page 2.  ↩
  2. City Council minutes, July 3, 2018, Item 68265 (ordinance and Exhibit A-3, “CPA Proposal 3 — Alternative Version”), PDF pages 43–46.  ↩
  3. Proffer agreement, Ashville Park, L.L.C. and the landowners, including Betty B. Bourdon, R. Edward Bourdon, Jr., and Paul S. Bourdon, dated September 5, 2003, recorded March 5, 2004, Virginia Beach land records instrument 200400037759.  ↩
  4. Deeds to Sandler at Ashville Park, L.L.C., dated August 27, 2004, recorded September 1, 2004, Virginia Beach land records instruments 200400140052 (Betty B. Bourdon, 56.4725 acres, $1,187,474, GPIN 2413-46-4337) and 200400140053 (Howard R. Sykes, Jr., Trustee under the Will of Stephen Paul Brown, 60.0395 acres, $1,260,829.50, GPIN 2413-55-5252); each says “Prepared by:  R. Edward Bourdon, Jr., Esq.”  ↩
  5. City Council minutes, August 7, 2018, Item 68366 (HOFD Ashville Park, LLC modification of proffers, approved by consent, Vice Mayor Wood moving, Council Lady Wilson seconding, 9-0), PDF page 190; Second Amendment to Proffered Covenants, Restrictions and Conditions, dated May 18, 2018, “Prepared By:  R. Edward Bourdon, Jr., Esquire,” Sykes, Bourdon, Ahern & Levy, P.C., PDF page 202.  ↩
  6. Deed, Paul Stephen Bourdon, R. Edward Bourdon, Jr., and Betty B. Bourdon and Robert E. Bourdon, her husband, to Paul S. Brown Family, L.L.C., July 12, 2007, Virginia Beach land records instrument 200700097830 (reciting that Doris B. Lawrence was survived by “her sister Betty B. Bourdon and her nephews R. Edward Bourdon, Jr. and Paul Stephen Bourdon,” and that Claude Paul Brown “devised all his real property to R. Edward Bourdon, Jr. and Paul S. Bourdon”); deed, executors of Stephen Paul Brown to Betty B. Bourdon, December 29, 1969, Deed Book 1144, page 643.  ↩
  7. City of Virginia Beach property records, November 20, 2026:  1928, 1942, and 1701 London Bridge Road; deeds 200700097830 and 200800005315; road closure, Ordinance 2864H, February 22, 2005.  ↩
  8. Deed of trust, Sandler at Ashville Park, L.L.C. to M. Kevin McCusty, trustee, $20,359,305, recorded September 1, 2004, Virginia Beach land records instrument 200400140061.  ↩
  9. City Council minutes, May 1, 2018, Item 68032 (“Ashville Park Update,” zoning history), PDF pages 57–60.  ↩
  10. HomeFed Corporation, Form 10-K for 2012, filed February 15, 2013, Item 1 (“Ashville Park”).  ↩
  11. HomeFed Corporation, Form 10-K for 2015, Item 1:  “As of December 31, 2015, all lots in Village A and Village B were sold.”  ↩
  12. City of Virginia Beach property sales records, Grandview Village at Ashville Park, March 31, 2023 to August 7, 2026 (52 sales); City site plans 2018-DSC-008559, 2020-DSC-012395, 2021-DSC-013484, and 2023-DSC-018401 (HOFD Ashville Park, LLC, c/o HomeFed Corporation; contacts Anthony Giacoia and Ryan Potes, L.M. Sandler & Sons, Inc.).  ↩
  13. City of Virginia Beach property records (soil type and FEMA zone), 313 parcels in the Ashville Park and Ranier Village subdivisions, November 20, 2026:  Hyde 192, Acredale 73, Nimmo 27, Dragston 11, other 10; all FEMA zone X.  U.S. Department of Agriculture, Natural Resources Conservation Service, Official Soil Series Description, Hyde series (drainage class:  very poorly drained).  ↩
  14. City Council minutes, May 1, 2018, Item 68032 (Cost Participation Agreement briefing, Deputy City Manager Thomas M. Leahy), PDF pages 64–69.  ↩
  15. City of Virginia Beach, “New Smart Stormwater Project in Ashville Park Helps Reduce Neighborhood’s Flood Risk,” March 22, 2023.  ↩
  16. City Council Summary of Council Actions, May 10, 2005, Item 5 (Sandler at Ashville Park, LLC, approved with minor changes), PDF page 4.  ↩
  17. HomeFed Corporation, Form 10-K for 2017, Item 1 (“Ashville Park”).  ↩
  18. WTKR News 3, “Ashville Park neighborhood under water, neighbors are hoping for a fix,” October 10, 2016.  ↩
  19. Agriculture Advisory Commission letter to Mayor and Council, April 16, 2018, in City Council minutes, April 17, 2018, PDF page 53.  ↩
  20. Memorandum, Deputy City Manager Thomas M. Leahy to City Manager David L. Hansen, “Ashville Park Stormwater Project – Cost Participation,” April 27, 2018, page 2, sent to Council with City Manager Hansen’s letter of the same date.  ↩
  21. City Council minutes, May 15, 2018, Item 68113 (ordinance to further describe the uses of the Agriculture Reserve Program Special Revenue Fund, including “a one-time use of ARP Special Revenue Fund fund balance for CIP 7-047, ‘Ashville Park Drainage Improvements’”), PDF pages 136–137; Councilman Uhrin absent.  ↩
  22. City Council minutes, July 3, 2018, Item 68252 (briefing on CPA Proposals 1, 2, and 3 and Mayor Jones’s Proposed Alternative), PDF pages 11–14.  ↩
  23. City Council minutes, July 3, 2018, Item 68268 (HOFD Ashville Park, LLC, deferred to August 7, 2018; “Eddie Bourdon, Attorney for Applicant, spoke in SUPPORT”), PDF page 50.  ↩
  24. City Council minutes, August 7, 2018, Item 68355 (transfer from CIP 7-151 Eastern Shore Drive Drainage Phase I to CIP 7-047 Ashville Park Drainage Improvements Phase I, “intended” to be restored in FY 2019-20), PDF pages 169–170.  ↩
  25. City Council minutes, August 7, 2018, Item 68366, composite list of proffers, proffer 21 (2018 Proffers), PDF page 196.  ↩
  26. WYDaily, “The city is pumping down levels of Ashville Park drainage ponds.  Here’s why,” October 9, 2018.  ↩
  27. WTKR News 3, “Environmental group pushes for new solutions to Sandbridge flooding; city blames winds, climate change,” April 22, 2019.  ↩
  28. City Council minutes, September 15, 2020, Item 70809 (Council Member Henley’s comments), PDF page 27.  ↩

Last updated November 21, 2026.

Have records or evidence about this?  Email keepvbabovewater@gmail.com.

Comments

Leave a Reply